With the decline of party politics in Egypt, social activism is becoming increasingly relevant in the fight against the government’s new authoritarian policies and tactics. While Egypt’s ruling generals have developed a tight grip on power in virtually every sector of society, various activist groups have had at least some success in holding the government accountable for human rights abuses. It will take many more victories to counteract the entrenched repression, but these groups offer the best hope for changing Egypt’s current reality.
The Struggle
- Since 2013, four anti-authoritarian platforms—led by young activists, professional associations, student groups, and workers and civil servants—have shaped social activism in Egypt.
- Spontaneous eruptions of popular anger have also become politically significant.
- In contrast, opposition parties have become less significant. Unable to carve out a stable, independent role in Egyptian politics, they are gradually turning to activist initiatives to exert some influence.
- Young activists remain committed to single human rights causes, primarily focused on extrajudicial killings, forced disappearances, or torture in places of custody.
- Certain professional associations—particularly the Syndicate of Doctors and Syndicate of Journalists—have ramped up their demands for autonomy and freedoms of expression and association.
- Students are challenging the security services’ interference in their affairs and the presence of government and private security forces on campuses.
- Workers and civil servants remain highly engaged, continuing to voice the economic and social demands of organized labor.
- Citizens have frequently taken to the streets to protest specific government policies and practices, as well as accumulating human rights abuses.
The Impact
- The government is using repression, undemocratic legal frameworks, and aggressive judicial tools to try to extinguish social activism. A large number of activists have been detained and arrested.
- Yet, the activism has restored pluralist politics to professional associations and increased popular awareness of the daily instances of repression.
- Labor activism has not been quashed, despite the banning of independent unions and the frequent referral of protesters to military courts; nor has the government’s renewed co-optation of the General Union of Egyptian Workers silenced the protesting of deteriorating economic and social conditions.
- The government’s tactics have also failed to vanquish student activism. Students continue to hold protests and have successfully mobilized against pro-government candidates in student union elections.
- The frequency of popular protests has resulted in a relatively effective push back against the impunity of police personnel implicated in human rights abuses.
Introduction
Egypt’s ruling generals are cracking down on civil society and secular opposition parties and severely inhibiting Islamist movements. The regime has empowered the security services to exercise outright repression and since 2013 has enacted numerous undemocratic laws with little resistance from a submissive legislature. Meanwhile, the media has propagated populist rhetoric that legitimates the unchecked power of the generals and ridicules demands for democratic alternatives.
In the face of this holistic repressive campaign, various pro-democracy politicians and opposition parties have grown demoralized and lost hope. For them, the current Egyptian reality offers few opportunities to effect democratic change and protect human rights. Thus, at first glance, it seems that the new authoritarian government has succeeded in equating the post-2011 brief democratic opening with chaos and the worsening of social and economic conditions. Egypt’s civil society appears to be dominated by the military establishment and overshadowed by the double-sided image of an authoritarian government and a powerless opposition—reflecting just how effective the crackdown on liberal, leftist, and Islamist parties has been.
Since 2013, popular protests spearheaded by young activists, professional associations, student groups, and the labor movement have been shaping Egypt’s reality.
However, this picture ignores another crucial narrative: the emergence of resilient and adaptable social activism. Since 2013, popular protests spearheaded by young activists, professional associations, student groups, and the labor movement have been shaping Egypt’s reality as much as individual initiatives taking on human rights abuses and police brutality. These actors are linked by the absence of ideology and partisan banners and by their resilience to authoritarian tools and tactics. They hold the promise of restoring a degree of openness in the public space and of reviving pluralist politics despite the generals’ stiff resistance.
The Limitations of Party Politics
Parties on the right and left have taken one of two positions since the 2013 coup: either endorse or condemn the policies of the new authoritarian government. Neither position has prevented the decline of the parties’ political roles.1 Egyptian parties—facing a government that interferes systematically in elections to organize comfortable majorities and a security apparatus determined to restrict their outreach activities and to drown them in internal conflicts—have not been able to carve out a stable and independent space for their role in politics. The reality of marginalization has pushed some parties to deprioritize politics and move closer to collective actors such as student groups and the labor movement in the hopes of escaping the authoritarian grip. However, there too the government has limited the parties’ role using intimidation and prosecution.
Signs of Unwavering Support
Despite the current landscape, some political parties have opted to collaborate with the ruling generals to embed themselves in the legislative and executive branches of government. Their positions are not changing, even as the hegemony of the military establishment and security services is rising within the state apparatus and in key sectors of society. This trend is manifested most clearly in the ascendancy of the former minister of defense, Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, to the presidential office in 2014 and in the expansion of the army’s role in the economy.
Some political parties have opted to collaborate with the ruling generals to embed themselves in the legislative and executive branches of government.
Notable among these groups are the New Wafd Party, the Free Egyptians Party, the Congress Party, the Egyptian Social Democratic Party, the Nation’s Future Party, the Democratic Front, and the National Progressive Unionist Party. The Wafd and Social Democratic parties led the formation of the first cabinet after the 2013 coup and enjoyed strong representation in the Constituent Assembly tasked with amending the country’s constitution. Other parties, including the Free Egyptians, Nation’s Future, and Congress parties, have endorsed governmental policies without equivocation and have been rewarded with parliamentary representation.
In the 2015 parliamentary elections, the pro-authoritarian parties nominated candidates and won seats in the House of Representatives.2 The Free Egyptians Party gained sixty-five seats, while the Nation’s Future and Wafd parties won fifty-three and thirty-five seats, respectively. Smaller parties also won seats: for example, twelve seats went to the Congress Party, four seats to the Social Democratic Party, and one seat to the Unionist Party.3 Although the security services promoted non-party-affiliated candidates and made sure they earned a majority of the seats, the pro-authoritarian parties, apart from the Social Democratic Party, have not faltered in their support for the ruling generals.
These parties also continue to tout the government’s populist rhetoric.4 They describe the 2013 coup as a revolution against Islamist fascism, deny the role of the military establishment and security services in human rights abuses, and frequently blame the Muslim Brotherhood—and less frequently pro-democracy groups—for sowing the seeds of violence and instability in Egypt.5 The leftist Unionist Party, for example, issued a statement in June 2015 lauding the 2013 coup:
[It] was an unprecedented popular revolution that aimed to save the Egyptian society and the nation from the terrorist Muslim Brotherhood and to end the rule of the Brotherhood’s Guidance Office. It saved Egypt from conspiracies (put forward by domestic, regional, and international enemies) to break up the state and destroy the nation’s army. It saved Egypt from the terrorist militias of the Muslim Brotherhood that violently tried to tear our society along sectarian, religious, and ideological dividing lines.6
The liberal-leaning Free Egyptians Party has employed similar rhetoric to mythologize the coup as a revolution and to portray the ruling generals as saviors and modernizers.7 The party stated that it was necessary to maintain the 2013 revolutionary spirit to “carry out the more important revolution: the revolution of work, production, knowledge, and social revolution and the revolution in religious discourse.”8 In various other statements, it frequently used the government’s assertions that Egypt was on the path to a democratic transition and that the creation of a modern civil state and the emancipation of politics from religion were in sight.9 The party has even accused the Muslim Brotherhood of being driven by fascists and supporting terrorism, while claiming that the military establishment and security services are being unjustly implicated in human rights abuses.10
Signs of Opposition
While some parties have shown unwavering support, others have opposed the generals from the beginning or have switched to emerging opposition platforms over time. Several liberal and leftist parties have distanced themselves from the new authoritarian government as of early 2017, after initially siding with the generals as they performed the 2013 coup and remaining silent about their crackdown on voices of dissent and pro-democracy groups.
While some parties have shown unwavering support, others have opposed the generals from the beginning or have switched to emerging opposition platforms over time.
For example, the Constitution Party participated extensively in the immediate post-coup power arrangement. Mohamed ElBaradei, the party’s founder, was appointed vice president on July 9, 2013.11 Other key figures participated in the first cabinet after the coup and in the Constituent Assembly.12 However, ElBaradei resigned on August 14, 2013, in protest of the forced dispersal and mass killing of Muslim Brotherhood supporters during their sit-ins. He accused the government of violating basic human rights and shedding blood instead of searching for political solutions to the Islamist opposition to the coup. Since the founder’s resignation, party leaders have gradually begun to oppose the ruling generals and their new authoritarian tactics.
Other parties have found themselves in similar situations, most notably the left-leaning Socialist People’s Alliance Party and the Nasserist Dignity Party. Along with several smaller liberal and leftist parties, they coalesced to form a platform named the Democratic Current.13 Since late 2013, the Democratic Current has grown more vocal in its opposition. It has issued several statements to condemn the passing of undemocratic laws, such as the Protest Law and the Terrorism Law, and to call on the government to end human rights abuses, including torture, forced disappearances, and the referral of civilians to military trials.14 In the 2014 presidential election, the Democratic Current refused to support Sisi and instead backed Hamdeen Sabahy, a leftist political veteran and a founding member of the Dignity Party.15
The opposing platform has pushed back against the government’s repression, condemning the detention for political purposes of scores of young Egyptians, the involvement of the security services in torture, and the use of excessive force against peaceful demonstrators and protesting workers.16 It has supported independent nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) facing rising pressure from the government—including forced closures and the banning of various activists from travel.17 And it has stood in solidarity with workers’ groups and members of professional associations defending the freedoms of association and expression.18
As a result of its efforts, the Democratic Current continues to garner the support of other disenchanted parties, such as the Social Democratic Party.19 This party repositioned itself after severe internal tensions and resignations en masse, led by the party’s foremost pro-authoritarian members.20 The opposition also includes parties that did not endorse the 2013 coup from the beginning. As the ruling generals were ascending to power in 2013 and 2014, these parties moved from reserved opposition to full-fledged rejection. The Strong Egypt Party, with semi-liberal and semi-religious leanings, emerged in this context, as did the Bread and Freedom Party that has garnered the support of young leftist activists and students.21 Both parties boycotted the 2014 presidential and 2015 parliamentary elections because of the government’s systematic interference that undermined any democratic potential. They have also criticized the government’s involvement in human rights abuses and collaborated with young activist protesters, student groups, professional associations, and the labor movement.22
In a formal political arena controlled by the military establishment and security services, making critical statements about official policies has become the opposition’s primary tool. Some independent parliamentarians, as well as the few parliamentarians representing the Democratic Current and the Social Democratic Party, have used their seats to establish a parliamentary coalition that has become an opposing voice in the House of Representatives.23 Yet, the sweeping pro-government majority has sustained the rubber-stamp character of Parliament and has ensured that the body’s legislative and oversight roles remain limited.24 The government’s tight grip on power continues to successfully marginalize political parties and quell their opposition efforts.
Little Challenge to the Authoritarian Surge
The growing opposition of some liberal and leftist parties has not prevented the generals from closing the pubic space or mocking formal politics. Statements condemning undemocratic laws have not forced the government to change its position.25 Similarly, increased criticism of human rights abuses has not discouraged the security services from conducting wide-scale repression.26 The Democratic Current and other opposing political parties have been unable to stymie the oppression of independent NGOs, professional associations, and organized labor. In other words, the actions of opposition parties have not elicited any real change in the policies that the government has implemented since 2013, nor in the power arrangement that emerged to subjugate citizens and society to the domination of the military establishment and security services.27
The growing opposition of some liberal and leftist parties has not prevented the generals from closing the pubic space or mocking formal politics.
In fact, the government’s response has been to implement even harsher policies. For example, in 2016, members of the Syndicate of Doctors publicly protested repeated police attacks on physicians and nurses administering medical support in public hospitals.28 To demonstrate solidarity and support, representatives of various opposition parties attended a general assembly held by the syndicate.29 Immediately after the meeting, citing the politicization of the doctors’ protests (through party involvement), the government moved legally and judicially to crush the syndicate.30
Similar events unfolded in the spring of 2016. The Syndicate of Journalists was at the core of peaceful protests against a maritime border agreement signed between Egypt and Saudi Arabia, based on which the Egyptian government recognized Saudi Arabia’s sovereignty over the Egyptian-administered Red Sea islands of Tiran and Sanafir. The agreement sparked popular protests, led by young activists and various liberal and leftist opposition parties that for the first time since the 2013 coup seemed willing to confront the government. The syndicate’s headquarters became the geographical focal point for the opposition.31 In response, and once again citing the politicization of the syndicate’s role by the opposition parties, the government ordered the security services to encircle the syndicate for several days and to close all roads leading to it. Security forces arrested journalists participating in the protests, accused the elected board of the syndicate of inciting violence, and drummed up litigation against three members of the elected board.32
Aware of the limitations imposed on their roles in the public space and in formal politics, opposition parties have sought new outreach activities. Some parties, especially the Strong Egypt and Bread and Freedom parties, have attempted to organize loyal student groups. Other parties, such as those part of the Democratic Current, have focused their actions on preparing candidates for the municipal elections scheduled for 2017, articulating bold plans to contest the presidential elections in 2018, and highlighting the ongoing economic and social failures of the ruling generals as well as their human rights abuses.33
However, even these activities have not altered the structural weakness of opposition parties. Targeted constituencies—such as young activists, students, and the urban middle class, particularly affected by the deteriorating living conditions in Egypt—have lost their trust in parties and party politics. Contributing factors have been (1) the flip-flopping of some parties between legitimating the 2013 coup and later rejecting the policies of the generals, (2) the initial silence of several opposition parties regarding human rights abuses, and (3) the continued failure of all opposition parties to articulate concrete policy platforms that offer sound solutions for the country’s economic and social problems.
Perhaps realizing the parties’ incapacity to effect change and loss of constituency support, Egypt’s ruling generals have focused more on cracking down on Islamist movements, independent NGOs, and other emerging activist groups.
Perhaps realizing the parties’ incapacity to effect change and loss of constituency support, Egypt’s ruling generals have focused more on cracking down on Islamist movements, independent NGOs, and other emerging activist groups.34 Only a few cases of detention and a limited number of arrest warrants have been reported in relation to members of opposition parties. Also, party leaders have not faced the ongoing defamation campaign from the government-controlled public and private media.
The Splintering of Islamist Movements
Different Islamist movements have exhibited different trajectories since 2013. Some have experienced the full brunt of government-sponsored repression because of their opposition to the authoritarian power arrangement. Others have sided with the government and accepted co-optation to avoid being targeted. While opposition Islamists have been forcefully pushed out of politics, co-opted Islamists have held on to what slivers of legitimacy and spaces for activity they can find. However, the splintering of Islamist movements has resulted in a tangible decline in their political significance.
The Muslim Brotherhood has been one of the regime’s prime targets. In the summer of 2013, the Brotherhood was at the core of what the government called “enemies of the nation.”35 Several Brotherhood leaders were arrested either a few hours before the coup or in its immediate aftermath. The Brotherhood’s protest sit-ins—which were organized following the coup to demand the return of the former elected president, Mohamed Morsi—were forcefully dispersed by the military and security forces.36 As of early 2017, arrests of the Brotherhood’s rank and file have continued in large numbers.37 The security services have been systematically involved in human rights abuses, including the extrajudicial killing of Brotherhood members, the torture of some prisoners and detainees, and the neglect of the medical needs of others in custody.38
The government has also used various legal and judicial instruments to repress the Muslim Brotherhood. In September 2013, a court ordered that the movement be banned and its financial assets be frozen.39 In December 2013, the government declared the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organization, mandating its dissolution and again calling for the freezing of its financial assets.40 In August 2014, the administrative court system revoked the license of the Brotherhood’s Freedom and Justice Party and mandated its dissolution.41
All this has been unfolding in a public space void of freedom of expression and injected with government-backed hate speech and hostility toward the Muslim Brotherhood.42 Charges of undermining Egypt’s stability, sabotaging the national economy, and disrupting developmental efforts have been leveled against the Brotherhood.43 The government has also intentionally conflated the Brotherhood’s agenda with that of jihadist groups to stigmatize the movement with labels of extremism and terrorism.44
In part as a result of this, the Muslim Brotherhood’s political significance has declined. Its exclusion from formal politics, the ban of the movement and its party, and the government-sponsored branding of the movement as a terrorist entity have shaken its popular base.
In addition, the Brotherhood’s organizational capacities have weakened considerably due to various fissures within the movement between the elders and the youth, the pragmatic doves and the ideological hawks, and the nonviolent and violent factions.45 In particular, the elders have used their financial influence to retain control over the movement and, in doing so, have alienated the young and middle-aged rank and file.46 Young leaders have gradually become more forceful in their opposition to the elders.47 A key issue of contestation is the use of violence, which some young leaders regard as a legitimate tool in the struggle against the new authoritarian tactics.48 The result has been the emergence of violent splinter groups within the Brotherhood, such as the Revolutionary Punishment Movement and the Egypt Arms Movement.49 Due to the sustained and systematic government repression of the Muslim Brotherhood, the probability of internal conflicts and defections within the movement will continue to rise.50
Due to the sustained and systematic government repression of the Muslim Brotherhood, the probability of internal conflicts and defections within the movement will continue to rise.
Other opposition groups in the Islamist spectrum have exhibited similar trends. Al-Jamaa al-Islamiya (the Islamic Group) and its political party, Construction and Development, along with the Center Party have faced internal conflicts and defections of young members—some of which have become more amenable to radical ideas and toying with violence as a legitimate tool.51
However, neither the Muslim Brotherhood nor other opposition Islamist groups have completely disintegrated. Some of their mobilization and organizational capacities have remained intact. Between 2013 and 2016, Brotherhood members carried out different protest activities across the country to demand either the release of their imprisoned leaders or to voice economic, social, and political concerns.52 As of early 2017, the Brotherhood has continued to mobilize some of its members to participate in popular protests against the government’s economic policies.53 Also, the fact that mass resignation of the Brotherhood’s and other opposition Islamists’ rank and file has not happened since 2013 testifies to the continued presence of some organizational capacities.54 Sweeping generalizations regarding the total eradication of opposition Islamists are misplaced.
Meanwhile, Islamist movements that chose in 2013 to support the coup and side with the generals have also lost political significance and presence in society. And they are in no better position than the Islamist opposition to counter this erosion.
Pro-government Salafis did not face the fate of the Brotherhood and other Islamists that chose to defy the will of the new regime.55 They avoided being banned and were given stakes in the post-2013 power arrangement. For example, after the Alexandrian Salafi Missionary Group and its political party, al-Nur, assisted the military establishment and security services in preparing for the 2013 coup,56 they were included in the Constituent Assembly and allowed to have access to the government-controlled media.57
The Salafi group and its party endorsed the former minister of defense for president in 2014.58 In return, they were free to field candidates in the 2015 parliamentary elections. These pro-government Salafis expected to gain a significant number of seats in the legislature, but that expectation proved to be misguided. The regime’s need for Salafi support has declined as its crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood has ramped up and the government has gained more control over official religious institutions.59 As a result, al-Nur was given only twelve seats in the House of Representatives.60 This is in stark contrast to the 2012 parliamentary elections, in which the party landed nearly 111 seats.61
Against the backdrop of declining party politics and the inability of both pro-government and opposition parties to influence government policies, other collective actors have advanced to articulate democratic demands and contest the unchecked power of the ruling generals. Egypt’s political reality has been shaped by the activism of these actors and by their resilience when faced with authoritarian tools and tactics.
Freedom for the Brave and Other Single-Cause Initiatives
Since 2013, young activists, students, and human rights groups have taken the helm of numerous advocacy initiatives. They often lack organizational capabilities and remain committed to a single cause related to human rights abuses, such as extrajudicial killings, forced disappearances, or torture in places of custody. In aiming to raise citizens’ awareness and mobilize them to demand an end to human rights abuses, these initiatives have to navigate a social and political environment in which large segments of the population are either resigned and less interested in standing up for the victims of abuses or simply fearful of being targeted themselves by an increasingly repressive government. This represents a significant departure from the pre–2013 coup environment in which similar advocacy initiatives were able to mobilize citizens with less fear.
For example, before the 2011 revolution, the We Are All Khaled Said Facebook page was instrumental in drawing public attention to the death of the young Alexandrian Khaled Said at the hands of the security services. It focused on two demands: ending torture and holding accountable the security officials implicated in acts of torture. The page administrators called for the popular protests on January 25, 2011, that culminated in the revolution.62 In the fall of 2011, the Maspero Youth Union was formed to demand justice and accountability for Egypt’s Coptic Christians after army and police forces killed dozens of them during a rally to protest increased sectarian violence and attacks on churches.63 The union’s activism has sustained public awareness about the incident and challenged the government’s attempts to erase the memory. However, army and police officers implicated in the Maspero killing have yet to be held accountable.64
In post-2013 Egypt, Freedom for the Brave represents the most significant example of a single-cause initiative.65 A group of lawyers, young activists, students, and journalists launched the initiative in 2014 to support victims of political detention and prisoners of conscience and to improve conditions in prisons and other places of custody. The group formed primarily in response to the mass arrest of more than 1,000 citizens by the security services on the third anniversary of the 2011 revolution.66 The press statement announcing the initiative refers to its members’ determination to carry out “vigils and marches to demand the release of all political detainees and prisoners,” including those victims affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood and other Islamist movements whose involvement in acts of violence or terrorism remains unsubstantiated.67 Since 2014, Freedom for the Brave has spearheaded attempts to shed light on human rights abuses committed against young activists, students, and members of the Muslim Brotherhood.
In particular, Freedom for the Brave has been a champion for the rights of victims of forced disappearances. The group has documented several cases of both forced disappearances and police detention without judicial investigations. The reports have been informed by direct contact with victims’ families and information provided by human rights and legal assistance organizations.68
Freedom for the Brave has also been attempting to raise public awareness about the gravity of human rights abuses and the deteriorating conditions for prisoners and detainees. For example, in February 2014, the group launched a campaign called Support Them, in which interested citizens send telegrams to the general prosecutor and the National Council for Human Rights to inquire about the treatment and health status of prisoners and detainees and to demand that prisoners’ complaints investigated.69 In June 2016, the group also started a media campaign to draw attention to the negative psychological and physical repercussions of solitary confinement, a widely used punishment in prisons.70
Freedom for the Brave depends primarily on social media networks to disseminate information about specific victims and to organize activities designed to demonstrate solidarity with them. Lawyers associated with the initiative have taken up several cases for imprisoned victims, identified the litigation against them, and argued in their defense in court. Additionally, these lawyers have documented human rights abuses in prisons, such as torture, solitary confinement, and denial of medical treatment. Although these efforts have neither led to the release of prisoners nor improved prison conditions, they have made the prisoners’ stories accessible to the public and have revealed the details of the injustice they have faced.71
Individual group action [as opposed to collection action] is too limited and too fragile to take on the new authoritarian government in the streets and public spaces.
Freedom for the Brave has not been able to organize peaceful protests to draw attention to its cause. The government’s wide-scale repression and the draconian laws passed to criminalize freedoms of expression and association have made the cost of protesting immensely high.72 Fearing the arrest of its young activists and students, the group has refrained from calling for rallies or demonstrations. Individual group action, which lies at the core of Freedom for the Brave, is too limited and too fragile to take on the new authoritarian government in the streets and public spaces. But, organized collective action stemming from professional associations, student movements, and labor activism is not.
Professional Associations
Some professional associations have also been pushing back against the new authoritarianism on issues related to their autonomy and freedoms of expression and association. The Syndicate of Doctors and the Syndicate of Journalists in particular have taken on larger roles in the resistance since 2015.73 The elected boards of both syndicates have been instrumental in mobilizing the base—either by calling for emergency general assemblies or by other means—and in motivating members to peacefully oppose authoritarianism. The resulting activism has restored pluralist politics to professional associations, created new spaces for the resistance of authoritarian policies and practices, and significantly increased popular awareness about the details of daily repression in which the government is implicated. The role of Egypt’s professional associations today is reminiscent of the one they played in the 1980s and 1990s, in which they were at the forefront of challenging autocratic control over civil society and pushing for their autonomy by defending the right of members to elect the syndicates’ boards without security interference.74
The Syndicate of Doctors
In 2015 and 2016, there was a profusion of incidents, documented on social networking and other media sites, in which police personnel attacked doctors, nurses, and other individuals administering medical care in public hospitals. One event involved the arrest, assault, and death of a veterinarian in a police station.75 In another incident, two policemen attacked medical doctors at the government-run Matariya Teaching Hospital.76
In the wake of the Matariya incident, doctors at the hospital organized a full strike and closed the facility pending legal action. The two doctors who were attacked filed a legal complaint in a police station, accusing nine security agents of physical assault.77 The elected board of the syndicate issued a public statement to detail the incident and the reasons for the Matariya hospital strike. The board also filed a complaint with the general prosecutor, demanding that the security agents implicated be held accountable.
In response, the general prosecutor ordered the arrest of the security agents, but they were released a few hours later. The board perceived this action as a manifestation of the government’s arrogance and disregard for the legitimate demands of the syndicate.78 Consequently, nearly 10,000 doctors congregated at an emergency session of the General Assembly on February 12, 2016.79 Leading the protest and articulating the demands were two charismatic figures of the board: the president, Dr. Mohamed Khairy Abdel Dayem, and the vice president, Dr. Mona Mina.
Under the board’s directive, the doctors unanimously approved a package of decisions and demands to pass on to government officials. The syndicate called on the government to recognize the right of doctors to refrain from work if medical staff or facilities came under attack. The doctors also demanded that the general prosecutor act quickly to investigate police personnel implicated in attacks. The syndicate also lobbied both the legislature and government to immediately pass legislation clearly criminalizing attacks on medical staff and facilities, pushing for harsher punishments for such crimes.
Further, the syndicate asserted its right to hold protest vigils on February 20, 2016—known as vigils of dignity—for doctors who were victims of attacks.80 The vigils were held in numerous public and private hospitals;81 they were also supported by many pro-democracy groups, NGOs, and individual activists. The syndicates of journalists, teachers, engineers, and public transportation workers all expressed their solidarity with and support for the doctors’ protests.82 The protests garnered sympathetic attention from the general populace and placed their demands at the center of debates about rights and freedoms.
Caught off-balance by the scale of the protests and the evolving public interest in the matter, Prime Minister Sherif Ismail announced that the government was committed to accountability and intended to punish those involved in the attacks on doctors and hospitals.83 He confirmed his readiness to meet with the syndicate’s elected board and respond to its demands.84 These official statements were followed by the commencement of criminal investigations and subsequent trials against police personnel involved in the Matariya hospital incident. The unprecedented popular rally around the syndicate’s board caused the government to rein in the security services by instigating criminal proceedings and promising no further attacks on medical staff and facilities.85 The board celebrated this as a step toward rule of law, a guarantee of rights and freedoms in a society marred by repression and human rights abuses, and a milestone in the effort to end the impunity of the unruly security services.86
The government’s initial retreat, only disguised its long-term strategy to inhibit the doctors’ protests and intimidate the syndicate’s elected board.
The government’s initial retreat, however, only disguised its long-term strategy to inhibit the doctors’ protests and intimidate the syndicate’s elected board. Over the last year, the government has used its judicial, executive, and media tools to contain the syndicate’s activities. The administrative court system, which governs the syndicate’s affairs, issued a ruling annulling the decisions of the emergency General Assembly. And the government blocked the legal amendments that would have introduced harsher punishments for attacks on medical staff and facilities.87 The government-controlled public and private media launched a campaign aimed at discrediting the syndicate’s elected board, especially Abdel Dayem and Mina.88 The government’s intimidation of Mina went even further; the general prosecutor interrogated her about the statements she made regarding the government’s health policies that were described as being based on wrong information, inflammatory, and threatening to Egypt’s national security.89
Still, the government’s initial retreat in face of the doctors’ protests demonstrated that collective action aimed at defending rights and freedoms could to a degree restrict the government’s repressive behavior and limit the security services’ transgressions. The campaigns to discredit the syndicate’s elected board have failed to undermine popular sympathy for its actions; after interrogating Mina, the general prosecutor decided not to pursue charges against her.90
The Syndicate of Journalists
Since 2013, Egypt has become one of the world’s worst jailers and abusers of journalists91—currently only second to China in the number of journalists serving jail time.92 The elected board of the Syndicate of Journalists has (1) repeatedly demanded the release of its imprisoned members, (2) described the prosecution of journalists as an authoritarian policy aiming at undermining the free flow of information and freedom of expression, and (3) exposed the systematic interference of the security services in the affairs of the syndicate to discredit the board and spread discord between it and its members. In response, the authoritarian government has ignored the demands of the syndicate’s board and pursued a confrontational course.
In the spring of 2016, the syndicate’s headquarters in downtown Cairo was the site of major protests against the maritime border agreement between Egypt and Saudi Arabia. Thousands of journalists, students, and young activists, along with public figures, gathered at the syndicate on April 15, 2016, to peacefully demand Egypt’s withdrawal from the agreement.93 They denounced the agreement as the sale of Egyptian land to the wealthy oil kingdom.94 The April 15 gathering was larger than the doctors’ emergency General Assembly meeting. In fact, it was the largest assembly of citizens in any public site since the dispersal of the Muslim Brotherhood’s sit-ins on August 14, 2013, and it garnered broad popular support.95
While thousands of people peacefully protested and rallied in front of the syndicate,96 the security services arrested 110 demonstrators, including journalists.97 Further protests were held on April 25, 2016, but the security services surrounded the syndicate and closed roads leading to it, preventing the demonstrations. During the dispersal of the protests, they arrested hundreds of citizens, once again including journalists.98
Stepping up their repression, the security services got the general prosecutor to issue two arrest warrants for Amr Badr and Mahmud el-Saqqa, two journalists at the website January News Gate.99 In the arrest warrants, Badr and el-Saqqa were accused of violating the law and endangering national security by inciting violent demonstrations and gatherings.100 A few days after the warrants were issued on April 30, 2016, they started an open-ended sit-in at their syndicate’s headquarters. The security services responded by raiding the two journalists’ homes, prompting Badr and el-Saqqa to ask the syndicate’s elected board to express solidarity with them and publicly state that they were being targeted by the security services for political purposes. Although the board refrained from issuing a collective statement, some of its members spoke out in defense of the two journalists.101
On May 1, 2016, the security services stormed the syndicate and arrested Badr and el-Saqqa102—an unprecedented incident in the syndicate’s long and often rocky relationship with Egypt’s various authoritarian regimes. Never before had the syndicate’s headquarters been stormed.103 During their interrogation in the general prosecutor’s office, Badr and el-Saqqa were served with additional charges, including “attempting to change the constitution of the country and to undermine its republican system as well as its current government,” “violating the stipulations of the constitution and existing laws,” and “preventing state authorities and public institutions from carrying out their work”—violations that could land them prison sentences, if not death sentences.104
Many journalists perceived these actions as an attack on their independence. Yehia el-Qalash, president of the syndicate’s board, expressed strong dissatisfaction with the security services’ actions. He called on Egypt’s president to take the necessary steps to resolve the crisis and restore the dignity of journalists.105 Other board members also raised their voices in protest. The most prominent of these journalists included Gamal Abdel Rahim, the syndicate’s secretary general;106 Khaled el-Balshy, the chairman of the syndicate’s freedoms committee;107 and Mahmud Kamel, the secretary of the syndicate’s cultural committee.108 They sharply criticized the security services’ provocative actions and attempts to surveil and control the syndicate. They also called for the release of Badr and el-Saqqa and demanded an apology from the minister of interior, who had ordered the raid on the syndicate.
Additionally, on May 4, 2016, an emergency session of the General Assembly convened to address the security services’ raid and to articulate collective demands. Similar to the Syndicate of Doctors, thousands of journalists attended and rallied around the cause of defending their independence.109 The list of demands included the resignation of the minister of interior, an apology from Egypt’s president for the raid, the passage of legislation that eliminates existing jail sentences for so-called publishing crimes, and the release of all journalists imprisoned or detained under this pretext.110 Pro-government journalists largely boycotted the assembly.
The security services meddled in the syndicate’s internal affairs to create a rift between the elected board and pro-government journalists.
In contrast to the relatively subdued way it initially handled the demands of protesting doctors, the authoritarian regime dealt with the protests of journalists with a full arsenal of repressive tools and tactics. The security services meddled in the syndicate’s internal affairs to create a rift between the elected board and pro-government journalists. On May 8, 2016, for example, a group of journalists known to have close connections to the security services organized a so-called journalistic family meeting at the state-owned and state-run Al-Ahram newspaper.111 They issued a statement accusing the syndicate’s board of placing itself above “state authorities and public institutions,” practicing “politics,” and acting “as a political party that monopolizes the syndicate as a platform for its objectives.” These pro-government journalists tried to split the embattled board from the inside by highlighting that five board members attended the family meeting because they resented the board’s actions and its manipulation of the General Assembly.112
On May 28, 2016, the authorities summoned the board’s president, vice president, and secretary-general for questioning and interrogation by the general prosecutor on charges of aiding the escape of journalists Badr and el-Saqqa and publishing false news related to the details of their arrests.113 After the investigation, the general prosecutor referred the board’s members to a criminal court.114 The court sentenced them to two years in prison, but the sentence is being appealed.115
The bold position taken by the syndicate’s elected board has added a significant space for activism and resistance in Egyptian politics.
The government continues to escalate its campaign against the Syndicate of Journalists by ignoring the board’s well-founded demands for the repeal of jail sentences handed down for publishing crimes. It also continues to use pro-government journalists to sustain internal conflicts within the syndicate and to undermine the board’s authority. Moreover, journalists continue to be imprisoned. For example, on October 26, 2016, the general prosecutor issued arrest warrants for sixty-three journalists associated with news websites and media production companies allegedly affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood.116 However, the bold position taken by the syndicate’s elected board has added a significant space for activism and resistance in Egyptian politics. More than in the case of the Syndicate of Doctors, the elected board of the Syndicate of Journalists has combined activism in defense of its members’ rights in the face of repression with a broad challenge to the government’s authoritarian policies and practices.
Student Activism on University Campuses
Despite its repressive tactics, the government has also failed to vanquish student activism. Students have continued to hold protests and mobilize against pro-government candidates in student union elections.117 Still, the crackdown has been harsh. Egypt’s ruling generals have used laws, regulations, procedures, and security tools to subdue student dissidents. The government has employed private security companies to patrol public university campuses and has pushed university administrations to enforce harsh penalties against noncompliant students. The general prosecutor has transferred hundreds of student dissidents to criminal courts, and even more have remained in police detention.
In the wake of the 2013 coup, students affiliated with and sympathetic to the Muslim Brotherhood demonstrated at public universities to demand the return of the deposed president, Mohamed Morsi. Their demonstrations unsurprisingly led to altercations with the new regime and its security services. The security forces responded to a few instances of student verbal and physical violence with excessive displays of force and the mass imprisonment of students.118 In the first semester of the 2013–2014 academic year, there were 1,677 student protests at public universities across Egypt, with the largest numbers occurring at Al-Azhar University (whose campuses are scattered across several provinces of the country), Cairo University, Ain Shams University, and Alexandria University.119
In the face of increasing state-sponsored violence, several student groups gradually began to call for the wholesale rejection of the constitutional, legal, and political measures adopted by the government. Students’ demands gradually shifted away from emphasizing the return of Morsi to denouncing Egypt’s ruling generals for their crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood, liberal and leftist parties opposed to them, and independent NGOs. Students began to mobilize around the condemnation of human rights abuses and advocacy for students who experienced repression.
Between 2013 and 2016, student groups protested the ban of the Muslim Brotherhood and its branding as a terrorist entity. They condemned the mass killing of Muslim Brotherhood members and supporters during the violent dispersal of sit-ins on August 14, 2013. Students also took bold stances regarding the security services’ implication in human rights abuses on university campuses and elsewhere. They demanded trials for police personnel involved in student murders and forced disappearances and insisted on the immediate release of students imprisoned and detained for political purposes. Some student protests decried the provision in the 2014 constitution that referred civilians to military courts and the passage of undemocratic laws such as the protest and terrorism laws.120
Several student groups gradually began to call for the wholesale rejection of the constitutional, legal, and political measures adopted by the government.
In addition, efforts to restrain the role of the security services on campuses moved up on the student agenda. Between 2013 and 2016, students held vigils to oppose the September 2013 decision of Egypt’s Supreme Council of Universities that made administrative security units operating on campuses responsible for “maintaining security and preventing riots, violence, and bullying.” They also protested the legal right given to security units to issue arrest warrants and initiate litigation against students.121 The council’s decision essentially overruled a 2010 court ruling that banned the presence of any security units or forces on university campuses.122 Despite student protests and doubts about the legality of the decision, the security services have sustained their presence on campuses.123
Egypt’s authoritarian regime has engineered a far-reaching set of tools to repress student activism. In 2014, the interim president, Adly Mansour, amended the Organization of Universities Act to give presidents of public universities the authority to dismiss, without litigation, students charged by university administrations with subverting the educational process, endangering university facilities, targeting academic and administrative staff members, or inciting violence on campuses.124 Mansour’s amended law still allows dismissed students to appeal to academic disciplinary boards and even allows the appeal of dismissal decisions before the high administrative court.125 But since the amendment was made, university administrations have demonstrated a high propensity to take punitive action against students involved in protests. For example, in the 2013–2014 academic year, 1,052 students were referred to university disciplinary boards for investigation and more than 600 students were dismissed.126 Dozens more were prevented from completing exams.127
The judiciary has been supporting the repression of student activism by issuing harsh sentences, such as imprisonment and exorbitant fines for students arrested at protests and charged with endangering university facilities, rioting, attacking staff members, inciting verbal violence, and possessing weapons. The charges are typically based solely on statements by the security services.128
This campaign of repression continued in the 2014–2015 academic year and resulted in a decrease in the number of student protests. During the first semester, student groups organized 572 protests—most of which occurred, once again, at the universities of Al-Azhar, Cairo, Ain Shams, and Alexandria.129 Students participating in the protests included members of the Muslim Brotherhood as well as liberal- and leftist-inspired student groups, which gradually began to oppose the regime’s repressive tactics. These latter groups drew their members from parties such as the Egypt Strong, Bread and Freedom, Constitution, and Movement of Revolutionary Socialists parties.130
Frequent clashes on campuses between students and administrative security units and between students and private security units facilitated a dramatic increase in the overall number of security forces operating in university spaces. Violent dispersals of peaceful vigils became the norm, and they often resulted in mass arrests and even the killing of a few students.131 The regime continued to employ its other repressive tools to crush student activism, such as dismissal from universities, arrests, and court proceedings resulting in harsh sentences.132
In the 2015–2016 academic year, the political scene at Egyptian universities changed drastically. Vibrant student activism, which had characterized the two preceding years, seemed to largely disappear, revealing the efficiency of the government’s authoritarian tools.133 The few student protests to occur during this period consisted of vigils and demonstrations designed to show solidarity with imprisoned and detained students. But they did not go unpunished by university administrations and the security services. Thirty-two students were arrested during the first semester and fifty-two during the second.134 The arrests were made by either the administrative security units, private security forces, or police forces, whose visible presence on campuses continued. University administrations punished ninety-seven students by either dismissing them, preventing them from taking exams, or referring them to disciplinary investigations.135
The judiciary has been supporting the repression of student activism by issuing harsh sentences, such as imprisonment and exorbitant fines.
Despite the decline in student activism, two significant incidents in the 2015–2016 academic year demonstrated that student groups were not completely quashed. First, in late 2015, the government, through the Ministry of Higher Education, attempted to exert control over student union elections in public universities but was relatively unsuccessful. In October 2015, the Ministry of Higher Education instructed university administrations to exclude certain students from running in the elections. The effort targeted those allegedly affiliated or sympathizing with the Muslim Brotherhood and those who led or participated in antigovernment protests and faced disciplinary punishment. On October 8, the ministry issued a decree to enter these changes into law.136 The decree stipulated that union candidates should not be affiliated with organizations or entities that are criminalized under the law or declared terrorist. It also stipulated that candidates’ university records should be free of any disciplinary punishment.137
In November 2015, student union elections were held in public universities across the country, and three main student platforms participated. The Voice of Egypt’s Students Coalition, with strong ties to university administrations—and through them to the security services—pushed for the depoliticization of universities. Mostly liberal and leftist students aspired to oppose the new authoritarianism and reinvigorate student activism. And groups of independent students rejected ties to both the government and opposition; they portrayed student unions as being responsible for representing the rights and interests of the student body. The Muslim Brotherhood, meanwhile, was banned from fielding candidates, and it decided not to participate in the vote.138
These unanticipated [student union] election results demonstrated that student opposition to the government remained strong and that the government’s assault on student activism neither took politics out of university campuses nor silenced student groups.
Liberal, leftist, and independent students won most of the unions’ seats, much to the chagrin of pro-government candidates.139 Ties to university administrations, the security services, and promotion campaigns managed by the Ministry of Higher Education had failed to ensure the success of the Voice of Egypt’s Students Coalition.140 Two independent members of the student unions were elected to head the executive office of the General Union of Egyptian Students, an umbrella union. Abdallah Anwar, who was a student in the Faculty of Mass Communication at Cairo University, was elected president;141 and Amr al-Helew, who was a student in the Faculty of Engineering at Tanta University, was elected vice president.142 Both were known for their commitment to students’ rights and interests, their advocacy efforts for students who faced government-sponsored repression, and their rejection of governmental and security interventions in public universities.143
These unanticipated election results demonstrated that student opposition to the government remained strong and that the government’s assault on student activism neither took politics out of university campuses nor silenced student groups. These were the only elections in which pro-government candidates lost. Further, the security services had failed to control the process, as it had done during the presidential elections in 2014, the parliamentary elections in 2015, and the elections of professional association boards.
However, following the student union elections, the Ministry of Higher Education refused to ratify the results and therefore denied the elected union the legal basis for its existence.144 In December 2015, the ministry dissolved the executive office of the General Union of Egyptian Students, citing a procedural error.145 These steps underscore the ruling generals’ dedication to keeping public universities under their tight control. The regime continues to pursue student groups that resist its clampdown and that mobilize against security interventions in universities.
The second incident in the 2015–2016 academic year occurred in April 2016, when students joined other activist groups in holding vigils and demonstrations to protest the signing of the maritime border agreement between Egypt and Saudi Arabia. The protests highlighted that universities remain, to a degree, a site of opposition to the authoritarian government and its policies. Protests against the agreement originated in universities and later spilled into the broader public. Student groups and unaffiliated students organized massive protests between April 15 and April 25 in several public universities across Egypt, in tandem with the broader mobilization centered around the Syndicate of Journalists.146 As they did with the syndicate’s protests, the security services used excessive force to crush the student protests and arrested scores of students who later faced court proceedings.147
This response aside, students’ active participation in the April 2016 protests served as yet another indicator that their interest in public affairs and political matters has not been quelled and, more broadly, that the generals’ clampdown has not achieved the complete depoliticization of public universities. In different ways, today’s student activism revives the activism of earlier periods on university campuses. Egyptian students were part of the global student movement against authoritarian politics in the second half of the 1960s. And in the 1970s, they spearheaded the local democratic movement, articulating its demands for citizens’ rights and freedoms and for enshrining modern conceptions of government accountability in Egyptian politics.148 Throughout the long rule of former president Hosni Mubarak (1981–2011), universities—besides being the primary space for ideological contestation between secular and Islamist groups—continually challenged the government’s undemocratic policies and practices, and university students were plugged into political activism beyond the walls of their campuses.149
Labor Activism
Despite security surveillance, forced dismissals of labor activists, and referrals of labor activists and protesters to military trials, labor activism remains at the forefront of societal resistance to authoritarian policies and practices. Unionized workers in public and private industrial facilities, as well as civil servants in the state bureaucracy and local government, continue to demonstrate and organize strikes to articulate their economic and social demands and to defend workers’ rights to freedoms of expression and association.150 Protests by labor activists have even impacted key service sectors, such as public transportation and healthcare.
Over the last several years, labor activism has primarily focused on Egypt’s growing economic and social crises and the ongoing deterioration of living conditions for a majority of Egyptians.151 Workers and civil servants have been using different tactics to make their voices heard: formal complaints, gatherings and rallies, protest vigils, media campaigns, sit-ins, work strikes, and hunger strikes. Work strikes and protest vigils remain the most widely used tactics.152 While the total number of protests declined from 1,655 in 2014 to 933 in 2015, the frequency will likely hold steady, given that 493 were recorded between January and April 2016.153
Work strikes and protest vigils remain the most widely used tactics.
Economic and social demands were at the center of the majority of protests in all three time periods: 49 percent in 2014, 27 percent in 2015, and 27 percent between January and April 2016. These protests called for the payment of workers in public and private facilities who have had their salaries withheld, wage increases to balance the rising inflation rate, improvements in working conditions and safety benchmarks, and safeguards for the rights of temporary workers and civil servants. Other protests called for ending punitive measures (especially dismissals and arbitrary transfers), improving transparency and accountability standards and introducing systemic anticorruption measures in the workplace, increasing efficiency and productivity standards, and recognizing the right to enjoy freedoms of expression and association without fear of intimidation or repression.154
In response, the regime has used various administrative, security, legislative, and judicial tools to reject most of the protesters’ demands and to punish protest leaders. While the Ministry of Manpower and Immigration has settled some formal complaints and requests filed by workers and civil servants, most cases have been referred to labor courts in the absence of acceptable settlements with public and private employers. In the first quarter of 2016, the ministry settled 1,392 of 5,322 individual complaints and 303 of 1,561 collective complaints, referring the rest to courts.155 This equates to low rates of settlement for individual and collective complaints: 26 percent and 19 percent, respectively. Furthermore, in line with common governmental practices in Egypt, the ministry has resorted to providing temporary financial assistance and other short-term benefits to appease some workers and civil servants during times of frequent labor protests.156
Since 2013, authorities have arrested dozens of workers and civil servants for demonstrating and have enabled the arbitrary transfers and dismissals of dozens of others involved in protests in both public and private facilities.157 The government has co-opted the General Union of Egyptian Workers, which has helped the regime attack labor activists and suppress their protests. In 2015, the security services–controlled leadership of the union asked the president to issue a decree that criminalizes all work strikes for a year.158 Several union leaders also announced their intent to form so-called committees of workers to resist sit-ins and strikes and to participate in counter-protest activities aimed at safeguarding the stability and security of the nation.159
No presidential decree criminalizing strikes was issued, so in 2016, the union’s leadership reinforced its anti-labor-activism position. Union leaders continued to ignore the well-founded economic and social grievances of workers and civil servants.160 Of particular note, the union backed the government’s decision and various court rulings161—and later the Labor Unions’ Act162—that banned the formation of independent labor and trade unions and ordered the dissolution of existing independent unions. All of these unions have helped organize labor activism since 2011.163
Since 2015, the new authoritarian government has been undermining labor activism, using the same legislative and judicial tools it has used against professional associations and student movements. In 2015, the government built on the legislative prerogatives of the president to pass a new Civil Service Law, which significantly changes the employment conditions of civil servants. The law, approved in 2016 by Parliament after the insertion of a few minor amendments, makes civil servants’ jobs easier to terminate and undermines their right to regular wage increases.164 It affects more than 5 million Egyptians within the state bureaucracy and local government.
The judiciary, like Parliament, has enabled the regime to surveil, repress, and punish protesting workers and civil servants. Reportedly, criminal courts have handed down various prison sentences for labor activists, and administrative courts have issued rulings that allow workers and civil servants who participate in protests to be forcibly retired.165
The government has also used the security services to disperse vigils, demonstrations, sit-ins, and work strikes; and the security forces have occasionally resorted to excessive force, using live ammunition and rubber bullets. Instead of holding them accountable, the general prosecutor has issued arrest warrants for protesters and referred them to criminal trials with ambiguous charges that include violent bullying, blocking public roads, disrupting public and private transportation, refraining from work, demonstrating without formal authorization, preventing public and private facilities from carrying out their work, and disrupting public security.166 For example, in September 2014, a workers’ vigil that was protesting management practices in the government-owned Alexandria Spinning and Weaving Company and demanding the payment of late salaries ended in clashes with the security services. Fourteen workers were arrested, and some of them were injured due to the excessive use of force by the police.167 Similar protests have continued to happen elsewhere in government-owned companies across the country, either inspired by economic and social demands or in response to the termination of workers’ contracts and their subsequent dismissal.168
The judiciary, like Parliament, has enabled the regime to surveil, repress, and punish protesting workers and civil servants.
Additionally, on May 24, 2016, the general prosecutor referred twenty-six Alexandria Shipyard workers who had been arrested to military trials; the charges included refraining from work and protesting without formal authorization. This measure was the government’s response to a series of peaceful protests and vigils at which workers demanded wage increases, job security, workplace safety, and the improvement of efficiency and productivity.169 The Alexandria Shipyard workers demanded independent arbitration between them and the company’s management to reach a settlement, but the army-controlled management rejected this demand. The company has been classified as an industrial facility of the Ministry of Defense since 2007, so the management used the military police to quell the protests and arrest the labor activists who were later referred to military trials.170 This was a clear violation of constitutionally enshrined rights and freedoms that include the right of civilians to be tried in civilian courts.171
Despite the government’s continued targeting of protesting workers and civil servants, labor activism has remained resilient. The banning of independent unions, referrals of protesters to civilian and military courts, and state-sponsored violence have not dissuaded labor protests; nor has the government’s renewed co-optation of the General Union of Egyptian Workers silenced the economic and social demands of organized labor activists.
Spontaneous Eruptions of Popular Anger
Popular anger about specific government policies and practices has frequently erupted since 2013. Groups of citizens have mostly taken to the streets to protest the accumulating human rights abuses committed by the security services. These protests are different in that demonstrators are not part of discrete initiatives that have a lasting presence. The demonstrators rather come and go in response to various incidents of abuse. However, the frequency of these protests since 2013 has resulted in an effective push back against the “no limit to repression” policies implemented by the security services and against the impunity of police personnel implicated in human rights abuses.
Police brutality against citizens has been the major catalyst of popular anger. As of early 2017, extrajudicial killings and torture in places of police custody have topped the list of causes pushing citizens—living as far apart as the capital Cairo and small southern city Luxor172— into the public space.173 As the new authoritarian regime has tightened its control over traditional forms of media, both publicly and privately owned social media networks have played a more central role in raising citizens’ awareness of police brutality.174
In November 2015, hundreds of angry Luxor residents gathered to condemn the killing of a fellow resident, Talaat Shabib, inside the city’s police station.175 Police personnel had arrested Shabib on charges of possessing narcotic substances and taken him to the police station where he was tortured and ultimately killed. The police officers and agents involved attempted to cover up their crime by moving the victim’s body to the Luxor Governmental Hospital and claiming he had suffered a fatal heart attack. However, popular anger and social network activism in solidarity with the victim and his family forced the security services to yield. The Ministry of Interior announced the arrest of several policemen on charges of torture and murder and referred them to the general prosecutor.176 One officer was sentenced to seven years in prison, five policemen were sentenced to three years in prison, and seven others were acquitted. The Ministry of Interior was also compelled to financially compensate the victim’s wife and his sons in the form of 1.5 million Egyptian pounds.
Other protests have been similarly successful. In February 2016, hundreds of residents of the Cairene neighborhood al-Darb al-Ahmar besieged the Cairo Security Directorate after the death of a local driver during an altercation with a policeman.177 The driver’s parents and supporters gathered and chanted slogans denouncing human rights abuses and demanding the murderer be brought to justice.178 Meanwhile, social media networks and various news sites picked up on the incident and broke through the official barriers of denial and silence regarding the victim, the offender, and the responsibility of the Ministry of Interior.179 Again, in response to popular anger and heightened public awareness of police brutality, the interior minister apologized to the victim’s parents by publicly kissing the head of the victim’s father.180 The offender was arrested, and the general prosecutor referred him to a criminal trial.181 He was sentenced to twenty-five years in prison.182
The newfound leverage that groups of angry citizens have developed against the security services has at least raised the political and social cost of human rights abuses.
The newfound leverage that groups of angry citizens have developed against the security services has at least raised the political and social cost of human rights abuses. Yet, the cases detailed above still represent the exception rather than the rule, as demonstrated by hundreds of documented cases of extrajudicial killings, torture, and forced disappearances that remain unaccounted for.183 Despite some arrests of police personnel for extrajudicial killings and torture, and their subsequent referrals to a criminal trial under massive public pressure, human rights abuses perpetuated by the security services have not subsided since 2013. Glaring problems of impunity also persist.184
Moreover, citizens’ dissatisfaction with the government’s economic and social policies has not led to similar eruptions.185 This has been the case since 2013, even though the living conditions of most Egyptians have deteriorated. After years of political turmoil following the 2011 revolution, the poor and middle-class segments of the population have not regained their voices in the public space.
Despite the protests against incidents of police brutality, the few cases of sweeping popular support for doctors protesting police transgressions, and the demands of some activist journalists and students for the annulment of the maritime border agreement between Egypt and Saudi Arabia,186 it seems that fear tactics and repressive tools have proved effective in instilling silence.
Resilience Amid the Crackdown
Since 2013, four forms of anti-authoritarian platforms have shaped social activism in Egypt: (1) single-cause initiatives that are opposing specific human rights abuses and advocating for the rights and freedoms of the victims, (2) professional associations that are defending freedoms of expression and association, (3) student groups that are challenging the systematic interference of the security services in their affairs and the permanent presence of security forces on campuses, and (4) the labor movement that is galvanized by deteriorating economic and social conditions and by the government’s repression of labor activists. In addition, spontaneous eruptions of popular anger in response to human rights abuses have become politically significant.
Egypt’s new authoritarian regime—as part of closing the public space and cracking down on civil society and opposition political parties—has tried to manage these forms of social activism through repression, undemocratic legal frameworks, and aggressive judicial tools. It has intensified its efforts to intimidate professional associations, student groups, and labor activists. And it has expanded its targets to include young human rights advocates and citizens who have publicly stood against police brutality. Nothing has highlighted this fact better than the large number of young activists and students detained and arrested, as well as the systematic referral of protesting workers to military trials.
Egypt’s ruling generals may not be embattled yet, but with the crackdown on civil society and the decline of party politics, these activist groups currently offer the greatest hope for changing the tide.
However, the new authoritarian government has found it difficult to quash a robust and resilient activism scene. At times, the government has made concessions to the demands of professional associations and demonstrating workers. Angry citizens protesting police brutality have pushed the security services to apologize for their transgressions and to accept putting police personnel on trial. On a few occasions, student groups have mobilized successfully to challenge the security services’ tight grip on university campuses and to subvert authoritarian tactics and tools of control. Egypt’s ruling generals may not be embattled yet, but with the crackdown on civil society and the decline of party politics, these activist groups currently offer the greatest hope for changing the tide.
Notes
1 As of early 2017, Egypt has eighty-three registered political parties. “Dalil al-Ahzab al-Siyasiya al-Misriya” [Guide to Egyptian political parties], Egypt Information Portal, March 28, 2017, http://www.eip.gov.eg/Directories/Directory.aspx?id=56.
2 Hossam Bahgat, “Hakaza Intakhab al-Sisi barlamanoho” [Here is how Sisi elected his parliament], Mada Masr, March 8, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/03/08/feature/سياسة/هكذا-انتخب-السيسي-برلمانه/.
3 Mustapha ‘Abdel Tawab et al., “Bel-Arqam.. Kharitat al-Ahzab Taht al-Qoba” [In numbers.. the map of parties in Parliament], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, December 3, 2015, http://www.youm7.com/story/2015/12/3/بالأرقام-خريطة-الأحزاب-تحت-القبة-المصريين-الأحرار-فى-الصدارة-بـ65/2473711.
4 Nada Hafez, “al-Tayyar al-Sha‘abi: al-Waqe‘ Yu’aked Inana Afdal Halan Men Suriyya Wel-‘Iraq” [The popular current: The reality confirms that we are in a better place than Syria and Iraq], al-Bawaba, September 6, 2014, http://www.albawabhnews.com/773232; The Popular Alliance, “Bayan Hezb al-Tahaluf al-Sha‘abi ‘Na‘am Lel-Ma‘raka Ded al-Irhab Wel-Magd Lel-Shuhadaa’” [A statement from the Popular Alliance ‘Yes to the battle against terrorism and glory for the martyrs], al-Tahaluf, February 16, 2015, http://eltahalof.com/news/10091.
5 ‘Abir al-Mursi, “Fi al-Zekra al-Thaletha lel-Thawra.. Siyasyun: 30 Yunuyu Hafazat ‘Ala al-Dawla al-Misriya Men al-Tafkuk” [On the third anniversary of the revolution.. politicians: June 30 saved the Egyptian state from disintegration], Ahram, June 27, 2016, http://www.ahram.org.eg/News/191944/136/533582/متابعات/فى-الذكرى-الثالثة-للثورةسياسيون--يونيو-حافظت-على-ا.aspx.
6 Khaled al-Nadi, “Hezb al-Tajammoe‘ Fi Bayanuhu ‘An Thawrat 30 Yunyu: al-Ma‘araka Mazalat Mostamara” [The Unionist Party in its statement about the June 30 Revolution: The battle continues], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, June 30, 2015, http://www.youm7.com/story/2015/6/30/حزب-التجمع-فى-بيانه-عن-ثورة-30-يونيو-المعركة-مازالت/2246321.
7 The Free Egyptians’ Party, “Bernamej al-Hezb” [The party’s program], Hezb al-Misriyyin al-Ahrar, no date, accessed on March 29, 2017, http://almasreyeenalahrrar.com/برنامج-الحزب.
8 ‘Alaa Ahmed, “al-Misryyin al-Ahrar: ‘Alayena al-Takatuf Lel-Mohafaza ‘Ala Thawrat 30 Yunuyu” [The Free Egyptians: We have to unite to protect the June 30 Revolution], Misrawy, June 28, 2016, http://www.masrawy.com/News/News_Egypt/details/2016/6/28/876550/-المصريين-الأحرار-علينا-التكاتف-للمحافظة-على-ثورة-30-يونيو. The Egyptian Social Democratic Party positioned itself differently, arguing for a national fight against terrorism; ‘Abder al-Garhi, “al-Misri al-Dimuqrati Be-Bani Suwaif Yad’u al-Sha’ab Lel-Istifaf Li-Muwajahat al-Irhab” [The Egyptian Social Democratic Party calls on the People to stand united in face of terrorism], al-Bawaba, February 16, 2015, http://www.albawabhnews.com/1119100.
9 “al-Misryyin al-Ahrar: Nad‘am Mashru‘ al-Sisi Le-Benaa’ Dawla Madaniya Haditha” [The Free Egyptians: We endorse Sisi’s project to build a modern civil state], Baladna al-Yum, January 8, 2016, http://www.baladnaelyoum.com/183242.
10 “Ra’is Kutlat al-Misriyyin al-Ahrar Bel-Barlaman: al-Misriyyun Tasadu Lel-Irhab al-Fekri Lel-Ikhwan” [Head of the Free Egyptians’ parliamentary bloc: Egyptians faced the ideational terrorism of the Muslim Brothers], Mubtadaa’ News Agency, May 13, 2016, http://www.mobtada.com/video/video.php?vid=23857.
11 The Constitution Party, “Bernamej Hezb al-Dostur” [Program of the Constitution Party], Hezb al-Dostur, October 3, 2012, https://www.facebook.com/notes/حزب-الدستور-القاهرة-aldostour-cairo/برنامج-حزب-الدستور-1/264399043681126/; and “Ta‘yyin al-Barad‘i Na’eban Le-Ra’is Misr Wel-Beblawi Ra’issan Lel-Hokuma” [Baradei appointed Egypt’s vice-president and Beblawi becomes the prime minister], al-‘Arabiya, July 9, 2013, http://www.alarabiya.net/ar/arab-and-world/egypt/2013/07/09/تعيين-الببلاوي-رئيساً-للحكومة-وبدء-المشاورات-التشكيل.html.
12 Hend Mukhtar, “al-Yum al-Sabe‘ Yanshur al-Qa’ema al’Kamela Le-Tashkil Hokumat al-Thawra Be-Ri’asat Hazem al-Beblawi” [al-Yum al-Sabe‘ publishes the full list of the revolution’s government headed by Hazem al-Beblawi], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, July 16, 2013, http://www.youm7.com/story/0000/0/0/-/1164450.
13 Mohamed Nassar, “Ba‘d Rafd al-Indemaj.. Hal Tafshal Ahzab al-Tayyar al-Dimuqrati Fi al-Tansiq Bel-Mahliyyat?” [After the merging refusal.. Are the Democratic Current’s parties destined to fail in municipal elections’ coordination?], Misr al-‘Arabiya, July 17, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/الحياة-السياسية/1159927-هل-تفشل-أحزاب-التيار-الديمقراطي-في-التنسيق-بـ-المحليات؟.
14 The Egyptian Popular Current, “Bayan al-Quwa al-Siasiya Be-Khusus al-Mohakamet al-‘Askariya Lel-Madaniyyin” [Statement of political forces regarding putting civilians on military trials], al-Tayyar al-Sha‘abi al-Misri, November 24, 2013, https://www.facebook.com/TayarSha3by/photos/a.398028120233749.78301.397975316905696/592296440806915/?type=3&theater; Ahmed al-Khatib, “al-Qadaa’ al-‘Askari Yatamadad Fi Misr Wa Yankamesh Fi al-‘Alam” [The military judiciary expands in Egypt and declines in the world], Sasa Post, October 29, 2014, http://www.sasapost.com/courts-martial-expansion/; and ‘Abdel Rahman Salah, “al-Tayyar al-Sha‘abi Yad‘u al-Quwa al-Thawriyya Lel-Tawhud Le-Ilgha’ al-Mohakamet al-‘Askriyya Lel-Madaniyyin” [The Popular Current calls upon revolutionary forces to unite to end military trials for civilians], al-Fajr,quoted in Masress, November 26, 2013, http://www.masress.com/elfagr/1469008.
15 Abu al-Fadl al-Isnawi, “Foras Wa Tahadiyyat Fawz Hamdin Sabahi Fi al-Intekhabat al-Ri’asiyya” [Chances and challenges for Hamdeen Sabahi’s candidacy in the presidential elections], al-Badil, Feburary 23, 2014, http://elbadil.com/2014/02/فرص-وتحديات-فوز-حمدين-صباحي-في-الانتخا/.
16 Samar Salama, “Saba‘ Ahzab Totaleb al-Sisi Bel-‘Afaw al-Ri’asi ‘Aan al-Mo‘taqaliyn Wa Ta‘dil Qanun al-Tazahor” [Seven parties calls on Sisi to pardon political prisoners and to amend the protest law], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, June 21, 2014, http://www.youm7.com/story/0000/0/0/-/1737028; Kilani, “Hikayat Men Daftar al-Ikhtifaa’ al-Qasri” [Cases of forced disappearances], al-Watan, October 11, 2015, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/816481; and Khaled al-Shami & ‘Ala’ Sarhan, “Ahzab Todin al-Dakheliya: Lam Tastau‘eb al-Dars” [Parties condemn the ministry of the interior: It did not learn the lesson], al-Misri al-Yum, January 25, 2015, http://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/641039.
17 The Egyptian Popular Current, “Awqefu Istehedaf al-Modafe‘in ‘Aan Hoquq al-Insan.. Bayan Moshtarak” [Stop repressing human rights defenders.. joint statement], al-Tayyar al-Sha‘abi al-Misri, July 17, 2016, https://www.facebook.com/TayarSha3by/photos/a.398028120233749.78301.397975316905696/1028889823814239/?type=3&theater.
18 The Egyptian Popular Current, “Awqefu al-Hujum ‘Ala Horiyyat al-Sahafa” [Stop the attacks on the press], al-Tayyar al-Sha‘abi al-Misri, April 5, 2016, https://www.facebook.com/TayarSha3by/photos/a.398028120233749.78301.397975316905696/972863856083503/?type=3&theater.
19 The Egyptian Social Democratic Party, “al-Bernamej” [The program], al-Hezb al-Misri al-Dimuqrati al-Ijtema‘i, no date, accessed on March 29, 2017, http://www.egysdp.com/البرنامج.
20 Omniya ‘Adel, “Hezb al-Misriyyin al-Ahrar Yo‘len Indemam Qiyadat Men al-Misri al-Dimuqrati” [Free Egyptians Party announces social democrats’ leaders to join], Misr al-‘Arabiya, May 17, 2014, http://www.masralarabia.com/الحياة-السياسية/271165-حزب-المصريين-الأحرار-يعلن-انضمام-قيادات-من-المصري-الديمقراطي.
21 “Mataleb Bel-Qabd ‘Ala Abu al-Fottuh Wa Hal Hezb Misr al-Quwiyya” [Demands to arrest Abu al-Fottuh and to dissolve the Strong Egypt Party], Arabi 21, February 14, 2015, https://arabi21.com/story/809586/مطالب-بالقبض-على-أبو-الفتوح-وحل-حزب-مصر-القوية.
22 Heba ‘Abdel Sattar, “al-Mostaqiylun Men al-Tahalof al-Sha‘abi Yo‘lenun Ta’sis Hezb al-‘Aish Wa al-Horiyya Lel-Hefaz ‘Ala Ruh al-Thawra” [Resgining members of the Popular Alliance announce the formation of the Bread and Freedom Party to safeguard the spirit of the revolution], Ahram, November 25, 2013, http://gate.ahram.org.eg/News/422615.aspx.
23 ‘Abdel Ghani Diyab, “Sawt al-Mo‘arada al-Mabhuh Taht al-Qoba” [The opposition’s faint voice in parliament], Misr al-‘Arabiya, July 22, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/الحياة-السياسية/1169167-بالفيديو-ائتلاف-25-30-من-قالوا-لا-في-وجه-من-قالوا-نعم.
24 Khaled Hassan, “Ra’is I’telaf Da‘em Misr: Narfod Itehamena Bel-Saytara ‘Ala ak-Barlaman Wa Tamrir Qawanin al-Hokuma” [Head of In Support of Egypt Bloc: We reject the accusation of monopolizing parliament and of passing the government’s laws], Al-Monitor, May 24, 2016, http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/ar/contents/articles/originals/2016/05/support-egypt-coalition-parliament-interview-sisi-terrorism.html.
25 Mostafa al-Najar, “Khitat al-Neqabat al-Mostaqela Lel-Tas‘id Ded al-Hokuma.. 10 Khatawat Le-Muwajahat al-Tadiyyiq al-Hokumi ‘Ala ‘Aamalaha.. Abrazaha Tabeni ‘Adaa’ al-Barlaman Le-Matalebohom” [Independent unions’ plan against the government.. 10 steps to confront governmental restrictions.. most significantly adoption of their demands by MPs], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, December 13, 2015, http://www.youm7.com/story/2015/12/13/خطة-النقابات-المستقلة-للتصعيد-ضد-الحكومة-10-خطوات-لمواجهة-التضييق/2486654.
26 Ashraf ‘Azuz, “Wakil Majles al-Sha‘ab al-Sabeq: al-Qame‘ Mostamer Wa Awdaa‘ Hoquq al-Insan Fi Misr Zeft” [Former vice speaker of the People’s Assembly: Repression continues and human rights conditions in Egypt are terrible], Barlamani,quoted in Akhbarek Net, August 15, 2016, http://www.akhbarak.net/articles/22845138-المقال-من-المصدر-وكيل-مجلس-الشعب-السابق; Khalil al-‘Anani, “Misr: Al-Motaterfun Hum Akthar al-Mostafidin Men Siyasat al-Sisi al-Qam‘iyya” [Egypt: Militans are the prime beneficiaries of Sisi’s repressive policies], Noon Post, January 11, 2017, http://www.noonpost.org/content/16126.
27 Iman al-Waraqi, “al-Ahzab al-Siyasiya Fi Mahb al-Riyeh” [Political parties destabilized], Aswat Misriya, February 21, 2017, http://www.aswatmasriya.com/news/details/73324.
28 Yara Saleh, “‘Aduw Be-Majles al-Atebaa’ Yakshef Tafasil I‘tedaa’ Amin Shorta ‘Ala Tabib al-Matariya” [Member of the Doctors’ Syndicate reveals the details of a policeman’s attack on the Matariya Hospital doctor], al-Bedaya, January 28, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/01/28/105792.
29 “Jame‘ Tarikhi Hashed Lel-Atebaa’ Fi Misr Ihtijajan ‘Ala I‘tedaa’at al-Shorta ‘Aliyhom” [Historic assembly for doctors in Egypt protesting police attacks on them], BBC, Feburary 13, 2016, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2016/02/160212_egypt_doctors_protest.
30 Hazem ‘Adel, “Ghadan.. Nazar Da‘wa Wazir al-Seha Le-Botlan Qarar al-Atebaa’ Le-Waqef Qararat ‘Omumeyatehom” [Tomorrow.. Considering the minister of health’s appeal to annul the doctors’ decision regarding the general assembly’s decisions], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, October 8, 2016, http://www.youm7.com/story/2016/10/8/غداً-نظر-دعوى-وزير-الصحة-لبطلان-قرار-الأطباء-لوقف-قرارات/2913597.
31 “Ahzab Wa Noshtaa’ Yotlequn Hamlat ‘Misr Mesh Lel-Bai‘’ Le-Isqat Itafaqiyet Tiran Wa Sanafir Ma‘a al-Sa‘udiya” [Parties and activists launch ‘Egypt is not for Sale’ campaign to bring down the Tiran and Sanafir treating with Saudi-Arabia], CNN, April 22, 2016, http://arabic.cnn.com/middleeast/2016/04/22/egypt-opposition-campaign-tiran-sanafir; The Egyptian Social Democratic Party, “Bayan al-Hezb al-Misri al-Dimuqrati al-Ijtema‘i Defa‘an ‘Aan Wahdat al-Watan La Lel-Tafrit Fi al-Jozor” [Statement of the Egyptian Social Democratic Party in defense of the territorial integrity of the nation and in rejection to the selling of the islands], Al-Hezb al-Misri al-Dimuqrati al-Ijtema‘i, April 11, 2016, http://www.egysdp.com/d-127-دفاعا,عن,وحدة,الوطن,لا,للتفريط,فى,الجزر; Naglaa’ Solayman, “‘Joma‘at al-Ard Hiya al-‘Ard’ Da‘wat Lel-Tazahor Fi Maidan al-Tahrir” [Friday of ‘Land is Honor’ calls to demonstrate in Tahrir Square], Shoruq, April 12, 2016, http://www.shorouknews.com/news/view.aspx?cdate=12042016&id=37b175a3-cd76-467e-9c8c-d35fd57ec4e8; Sami Sa‘id, “Intefadat ‘al-Ard Hiya al-‘Ard’: Qabedun ‘Ala Jamr al-Helm Wa al-Amal” [‘Land is Honor’ uprising: Determined to keep the dream and the hope], al-Badil, April 15, 2016, http://elbadil.com/2016/04/انتفاضة-الأرض-هي-العرض-قابضون-على-جم/; ‘Abdallah Bedair, “Hamdin Sabahi B‘ad Hokm ‘Tiran Wa Sanafir’: ‘Aash Man Sanu Ard Wa ‘Ard Misr” [Hamdeen Sabahi after the ‘Tiran and Sanfir’ court ruling: Long live those who safeguarded Egypt’s land and honor], Misr al-‘Arabiya, June 21, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/سوشيال-ميديا/1120002-حمدين-صباحي-بعد-حكم-تيران-وصنافير-عاش-من-صانوا-أرض-وعرض-مصر.
32 ‘Abdallah Hamed, “Tafasil Wa Tad‘iyat Iqteham al-Amn al-Misri Neqabat al-Sahafiyyin” [Details and consequences of the Egyptian security storming of the Syndicate of Journalists], Al Jazeera, May 2, 2016, http://www.aljazeera.net/news/reportsandinterviews/2016/5/2/تفاصيل-وتداعيات-اقتحام-الأمن-المصري-نقابة-الصحفيين.
33 Biysan Kassab, “Mobadarat ‘Hamdin’: ‘Badil’ Ghayr Wadeh.. Wa Asa’ela Bela Ijabat” [Hamdeen’s initiative: Not a clear alternative and questions without answers], Mada Misr, March 7, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/03/07/feature/سياسة/مبادرة-حمدين-بديل-غير-واضح-وأسئلة-بلا/; Mostafa Mohie, “B‘ad Mobadarat ‘Hejji’.. Men Yofaker Fi Intekhabat al-Ri’asa 2018?” [After Heggy’s initiative.. who is thinking about the presidential elections 2018?], Mada Misr, August 7, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/08/07/feature/سياسة/بعد-مبادرة-حجي-من-يفكر-في-انتخابات-الر/.
34 Hajar ‘Othman, “Dr. Rabab al-Mahdi Fi Hewar Lel-Bedaya: Misr Ta‘ish Aswaa’ Lahazateha” [Dr. Rabab al-Mahdi in an interview with Albedaiah: Egypt lives its worst moments], al-Bedaya, June 15, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/06/15/115031; ‘Abdel Rahman Aiyad, “Kayfa Tara al-Mo‘arada al-Misriya Nafsaha Ka-Badil Siyasi?” [How does the Egyptian opposition sees itself as a political alternative?], Sasa Post, August 16, 2016, http://www.sasapost.com/egyptian-opposition/.
35 Ibn al-Dawla, “Ili ‘Aayzin Mosalaha Ma‘a al-Ikhwan.. Ishrabu.. al-Ikhwan A‘daa’ Lehaza al-Watan” [Those who want reconciliation with the Brothers.. Get lost.. The Brothers are enemies to this nation], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, June 8, 2015, http://www.youm7.com/story/2015/6/8/ابن-الدولة-يكتب-اللى-عاوزين-مصالحة-مع-الإخوان-اشربوا-الإخوان/2215781.
36 “All According to Plan: The Rab‘a Massacre and Mass Killings of Protesters in Egypt,” Human Rights Watch, June 12, 2014, https://www.hrw.org/report/2014/08/12/all-according-plan/raba-massacre-and-mass-killings-protesters-egypt.
37 On the evening of July 3, 2013, the police arrested Mohamed Sa‘ad al-Katatny, the speaker of the 2012 Parliament and chairman of the Freedom and Justice Party, and Rashad Bayoumy, deputy general guide of the Muslim Brotherhood. Both were charged with the murder of demonstrators in the midst of the popular protests that spread throughout Egypt in the summer of 2013. On July 5, Khayrat al-Shater, also deputy general guide of the movement, was arrested and charged with the same accusations. On July 29, the police arrested Abou al-‘Oula Mady, the chairman of the Wasat Party, and his vice chairman, ‘Essam Soltan. They were charged with inciting the killing of protesters and insulting the judiciary. In the wake of the brutal dispersal of the Muslim Brotherhood’s sit-ins in the Nahda and Rabaa squares on August 14, 2013, there were successive arrests of first-tier leaders. Mohamed Badie‘, general guide of the movement, was arrested on August 20, 2013. Mohamed el-Beltajy, secretary-general of the Freedom and Justice Party, followed on the 29 of the same month. Badie‘ and el-Beltajy were charged with inciting violence and killing during the sit-ins as well as conspiring with foreign countries. On October 30, 2013, the security forces arrested the vice chairman of the Freedom and Justice Party, ‘Essam al-‘Eryan and charged him the same set of accusations. By the fall of 2013, most Islamist leaders were imprisoned. Those leaders who were not imprisoned had to flee Egypt to avoid being arrested. They include Mahmud ‘Izzat, currently the acting general guide of the Muslim Brotherhood; Mahmud Hussein, secretary general of the movement; Mohamed Mahsoub of the Wasat Party, minister of parliamentary affairs under Morsi; and the chairman of the Islamist Construction and Development Party, Tarek el-Zomor. See Yosry Badry, “Masdar amny: al-Qabd ‘Ala Sa‘ad al-Katatny wa Rashad Bayoumy” [Security source: Sa‘ad al-Katatny and Rashad Bayoumy have been arrested], al-Misri al-Yum, July 4, 2013, http://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/230709; Samy ‘Abdel Rady and Mahmud al-Jarhy, “al-Neyaba Towajeh ‘al-Katatny wa Bayoumy’ be-Tohmet Qatl 22 wa al-Shorou‘ Fey Qatl 211 Fey ‘Majzarat Bayn al-Sarayat’”[Prosecutors accuse al-Katatny and Bayoumy for the murder of 22 individuals and the attempted murder of 211 in the massacre of Bayn al-Sarayat], al-Watan, July 6, 2013, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/219702; “al-Qabd ‘Ala Khayrat al-Shater al-Rajel al-Qawy Fey Jama‘at al-Ikhwan” [The arrest of Khayrat al-Shater the strong man in the Muslim Brotherhood], BBC, July 5, 2013, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2013/07/130706_ikhwan_shater_arrest; al-Walid Isma‘il, “‘al-Watan’ Tanfared be-Nashr Nas al-Tahqeeqat ma‘a Khayrat al-Shater Fey Qadeyet ‘Majzarat al-Irshad’” [al-Watan publishes the official text of the Interrogation of Khayrat al-Shater in the Irshad Massacre], al-Watan, August 18, 2013, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/266413; al-‘Arabiya, “al-Qabd ‘Ala ‘Essam Soltan wa Abou al-‘Oula Mady wa Tarhelahoma le-Tora” [The arrest of ‘Essam Soltan and Abou al-‘Oula Mady and sent to Tora Prison], al-‘Arabiya, July 29, 2013, https://www.alarabiya.net/ar/arab-and-world/egypt/2013/07/29/القبض-على-عصام-سلطان-وأبو-العلا-ماضي-وترحيلمها-لطره.html; “al-Azma Fey Masr: al-Qabd ‘Ala Mohamed Badei‘ al-Morshed al-‘Aam lel-Ikhwan al-Moslimeen” [Crisis in Egypt: The arrest of Mohamed Badei‘, the general guide of the Muslim Brotherhood], BBC, August 20, 2013, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2013/08/130820_egypt_badie_arrest; “I‘teqal Mohamed al-Beltajy al-Qeeyady Fey al-Ikhwan al-Moslimeen” [The Arrest of Mohamed al-Beltajy Leading member of the Muslim Brotherhood], BBC, August 29, 2013, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2013/08/130829_egypt_beltagi_arrested; Mohamed Sharqawy, “Masder Qada`ie Yakshef La`ehet al-Itahamat al-Mowajaha lel-Beltajy…al-Neyaba Tatahemohu bel-Tahreed bel-`Amr al-Mubasher ‘Ala A‘amal ‘Onf Fey Ahdath ‘Rab‘a al-‘Adaweya’ wa ‘al-Nahda’ wa ‘al-Haras al-Jumhoury’…wa al-Takhabor le-Saleh Jehat Ajnabeya” [A judicial source reveals the list of accusations directed at al-Beltajy, inciting violence in Rab‘a, Nahda, and the Republican Guard Incidents], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, August 29, 2013, http://www.youm7.com/story/2013/8/29/مصدر-قضائى-يكشف-لائحة-الاتهامات-الموجهة-للبلتاجى-النيابة-تتهمه-بالتحريض/1226351; al-‘Arabiya, “Ilqa` al-Qabd ‘Ala al-Qeeyady al-Ikhwany ‘Essam al-‘Eryan bel-Qahera” [The arrest of Muslim Brotherhood leader ‘Essam al-‘Eryan], al-‘Arabiya, October 30, 2013, https://www.alarabiya.net/ar/arab-and-world/egypt/2013/10/30/إلقاء-القبض-على-القيادي-في-الإخوان-عصام-العريان.html; al-Misreyun, “Ayna Ikhtafa Mahmud ‘Ezzat?” [Where did Mahmud ‘Ezzat disappear?], al-Misreyun, February 4, 2014, https://almesryoon.com/دفتر-أحوال-الوطن/814677-أين-اختفى-محمود-عزت- ؟; ‘Adel ‘Abdel Rahman, “Mahmud Hussein al-Ameen al-‘Aam lel-Ikhwan al-Moslimeen… le-Madha Istahadafohu be-Hadhahy al-Sharasa” [Mahmud Huseein the secretary general of the Muslim Brotherhood…Why did they pursue him with such vengeance?], Kalemty, June 9, 2015, http://klmty.net/379319-محمود_حسين_الأمين_العام_للإخوان_المسلمين___لماذا_استهدافه_بهذه_الشراسة_ ؟_.html; Mostafa al-Maghreby, “Mohamed Mahsoub Yakshef Tafaseel ‘Ard al-Sisi lel-Ikhwan Qabl Bayan 3 Youlyou” [Mohamed Mahsoub reveals the details of the deal Sisi gave the Muslim Brotherhood prior to the July 3 statement], Misr al-‘Arabiya, July 2, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/سوشيال-ميديا/1136121-محمد-محسوب-يكشف-تفاصيل-عرض-السيسي-للإخوان-قبل-بيان-3-يوليو; Magdy ‘Abdel Rasoul, “Masder le-Veto: Horoub Tarek al-Zomor wa ‘Essem ‘Abdel Majed be-Mo‘awanet Ajheza Seeyadeya… al-Amn Sa‘edohoma Fey al-Khorouj Men Masr Tajanoban lel-Sedam ma‘a al-Jama‘at al-Islameya…al-Qeeyadeyan bel-Jama‘a al-Islameya Harba Taht She‘ar al-Hejra al-Mou`qata” [Source to Veto: The escape of Tarek al-Zomor and ‘Essem ‘Abdel Majed in cooperation with high-ranked leaders…Security officials helped them to leave Egypt to avoid clashing with Islamist groups…The leaders escaped under the guise of “temporary immigration”], Veto Gate, December 2, 2013, http://www.vetogate.com/725701.
38 Sayyid Redwan, “Fi 3 Sanawat.. al-Marad Wa al-Rosas Yaqtolan 30 Qiyadiyan Wa Kaderan Lel-Ikhwan” [In 3 years.. Illness and bullets kill 30 leaders and operatives of the Brotherhood], Rassd, October 5, 2016, http://rassd.com/194225.htm.
39.Mohamed Hamama, “Lajnat al-Tahafoz ‘Ala Amwal al-Ikhwan Fi Muwajahat al-Qadaa’” [Committee to confiscate the Brothers’ money in confrontation with the judiciary], Mada Misr, November 24, 2016, https://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/11/24/feature/سياسة/لجنة-التحفظ-على-أموال-الإخوان-في-مواجه/.
40 “Misr To‘len al-Ikhwan al-Moslemiyn Jama‘a Irhabiya Yohakemha al-Qanun” [Egypt declares the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist group and subjects it to legal accountability], al-‘Arabiya, December 25, 2013, http://www.alarabiya.net/ar/arab-and-world/egypt/2013/12/25/مصر-تعلن-جماعة-الإخوان-المسلمين-جماعة-إرهابية.html. As of early 2017, the administrative court system is still considering appeals to the declaration of the Muslim Brotherhood as a terrorist organization. Mohamed al-‘Omda, “al-Qadaa’ al-Idari Yu’ajel Da‘wa Botlan Qarar Hal Jam‘iyat al-Ikhwan Ila 26 Yunyu” [The administrative judiciary postpones annulling dissolving the Brothers’ organization to June 26], al-Watan, April 17, 2016, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/1103378.
41 Mohamed al-‘Omda, “Haythiyat Hal al-Horiyya Wa al-‘Adala” [Legal reasons for dissolving the Freedom and Justice Party], al-Watan, August 10, 2014, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/536077.
42 Ahmed Samir, “Khitab al-Karahiya: Hal To‘id Misr Tajrobat Rwanda” [Hate speech: Will Egypt repeat the experience of Rwanda?], Idaa’at, February 14, 2016, http://ida2at.com/hate-speech-repeat-egypt-experience-ronda/.
43 Mohamed Shoman, “Kashef Mokhatat al-Ikhwan al-Hadama al-Hadefa Le-Darb al-Iqtesad” [Revealing the Brothers’ destructive plans to damage the economy], Ahram, September 25, 2016, http://www.ahram.org.eg/News/192034/38/552671/حوادث/كشف-مخططات-الإخوان-الهدامة-الهادفة-لضرب-الاقتصاد.aspx; Mahmud ‘Abdel Radi, “al-Dakheliya Tohbet Akbar Mu’amara Lel-Ikhwan Le-Darb al-Iqtesad” [The ministry of the interior upsets the Brothers’ biggest conspiracy to damage the economy], al-Yum al-Sabe‘, September 24, 2016, http://www.youm7.com/story/2016/9/24/الداخلية-تحبط-أكبر-مؤامرة-لـ-الإخوان-لضرب-الاقتصاد-التنظيم-الإرهابى/2894955; Mohamed ‘Abdel Halim, “Atlaqateha Men Torkiya.. Khetat al-Ikhwan al-Irhabiya Le-Darb al-Iqtesad al-Misri“ [Launched in Turkey.. The Brotherhood’s terrorist plan to damage the Egyptian economy], Dot Misr, August 28, 2016, http://www.dotmsr.com/details/أطلقتها-من-تركيا-خطة-الإخوان-الإرهابية-لضرب-الاقتصاد-المصري.
44 Amal Mahdi, “‘al-Ikhwan’.. al-Irhab Wa Tasaqot al-Aqne‘a al-Za’efa” [‘The Brotherhood’.. Terrorism and the fall of fake masks], al-Bawaba, January 3, 2014, http://www.albawabhnews.com/306253; Hani al-Waziri et al, “Khetat Isqat al-Dawla: al-Ikhwan Wa Mokhabarat Torkiya Wa Qatar Yabda’un al-Mu’amara Ded Misr 19 Nuvamber” [The plot to bring the state to fall: The Brothers and the intelligence services of Turkey and Qatar start their conspiracy against Egypt on November 19], al-Watan, November 12, 2013, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/354373.
45 Mohamed al-Mohandes, “al-Sira‘ Dakhel al-Ikhwan Bayn al-Selmiya Wa al-‘Onf 1” [the struggle within the Brotherhood between nonviolence and violence 1], Misr al-‘Arabiya, August 29, 2015, http://www.masralarabia.com/المقالات/201-محمد-المهندس/711757-الصراع-داخل-الإخوان-بين-السلمية-والعنف-1; Mohamed al-Mohandes, “al-Sira‘ Dakhel al-Ikhwan Bayn al-Selmiya Wa al-‘Onf 2” [the struggle within the Brotherhood between nonviolence and violence 2], Misr al-‘Arabiya, September 8, 2015, http://www.masralarabia.com/المقالات/201-محمد-المهندس/723219-الصراع-داخل-الإخوان-بين-السلمية-والعنف-2; Mohamed al-Mohandes, “al-Sira‘ Dakhel al-Ikhwan Bayn al-Selmiya Wa al-‘Onf 3” [the struggle within the Brotherhood between nonviolence and violence 3], Misr al-‘Arabiya, September 12, 2015, http://www.masralarabia.com/المقالات/201-محمد-المهندس/727543-الصراع-داخل-الإخوان-بين-السلمية-والعنف-3; Mohamed al-Mohandes, “al-Sira‘ Dakhel al-Ikhwan Bayn al-Selmiya Wa al-‘Onf 4” [the struggle within the Brotherhood between nonviolence and violence 4], Misr al-‘Arabiya, September 19, 2015, http://www.masralarabia.com/المقالات/201-محمد-المهندس/735641-الصراع-داخل-الإخوان-بين-السلمية-والعنف-4; Mohamed al-Mohandes, “al-Sira‘ Dakhel al-Ikhwan Bayn al-Selmiya Wa al-‘Onf 5” [the struggle within the Brotherhood between nonviolence and violence 5], Misr al-‘Arabiya, September 26, 2015, http://www.masralarabia.com/المقالات/201-محمد-المهندس/742935-الصراع-داخل-الإخوان-بين-السلمية-والعنف-5.
46 Mohamed ‘Abdel Halim, “al-Khiyanat al-Maliya ‘Toqate‘ Sharayyin’ al-Ikhwan.. Wa al-Da‘em Moqabel al-Walaa’” [Financial betrayals dismantle the Brotherhood.. Financial support in return for loyalty], Dot Misr, September 3, 2016, http://www.dotmsr.com/details/الخيانات-المالية-تقطع-شرايين-الإخوان-والدعم-مقابل-الولاء.
47 “‘Auagiz al-Ikhwan Yansebun Fakhan Le-Jabhat al-Shabab” [The elderly of the Brotherhood conspire against the youngsters’ front], al-Misriyyun, December 24, 2016, https://almesryoon.com/دفتر-أحوال-الوطن/994781-«عواجيز-الإخوان»-ينصبون-فخًا-لجبهة-الشباب; “‘Auagiz al-Ikhwan Lel-Shabab: Notalbekom Bel-I‘tezar” [The Broterhood’s elderly to the youngsters: We demand an apology], al-Misriyyun, January 18, 2017, https://almesryoon.com/دفتر-أحوال-الوطن/1011425-عواجيز-الإخوان-لـ-«الشباب»-نطالبكم-بالاعتذار.
48 Mohamed Hamama, “Bayan Jadid Le-Jabhat ‘Shabab al-Ikhwan’ Yu’asek Le-Istekhedam al-Selah Wa al-Takhali ‘Aan al-Selmiya” [A new statement from the Brotherhood’s ‘Youngsters Front’ legitimizes the use of arms and gives up nonviolence], Mada Misr, January 9, 2017, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2017/01/09/news/u/ورقة-داخلية-إخوانية-تكشف-تبنيهم-للعنف/.
49 Mai Shams al-Din, “Jama‘at al-‘Iqab al-Thawri.. Bayn al-Dawla Wa al-Jama‘a” [Revolutionary punishment groups.. Between the state and the Broterhood], Mada Misr, June 21, 2015, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2015/06/21/feature/سياسة/جماعات-العقاب-الثوري-بين-الدولة-والجم/; Mohamed Hamama, “Haraket ‘Hasm’ Ila al-Wajeha Ba‘d ‘Amaliyateha al-Thaletha” [HASM movement to the front after its third attack], Mada Misr, September 11, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/09/11/news/سياسة/حركة-حسم-إلى-الواجهة-بعد-عمليتها-الثا/.
50 “Erdogan: Torkiya Satoraheb Be-Qiyadat al-Ikhwan” [Erdogan: Turkey will welcome leaders of the Brotherhood], BBC, September 16, 2014, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2014/09/140916_turkey_qatar_muslim_brothers; Imil Amin, “al-Shatat al-Ikhwani Men London Ila Graz” [Brotherhood’s diaspora from London to Graz], al-Bayan, April 21, 2014, http://www.albayan.ae/opinions/articles/2014-04-21-1.2105892; Mada Misr, “al-Shatat al-Ikhwani: Kuwalis Khoruj al-Ikhwan Men Qatar” [Brotherhood’s diaspora: Behind the Brothers’ exodus from Qatar], September 26, 2014, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2014/09/26/feature/سياسة/الشتات-الإخواني-كواليس-خروج-الإخوان-م/.
51 “Fi al-Sojun Honak Motase‘ Lel-Jamie‘.. Taqrir Jadid Lel-Shabaka al-‘Arabiya” [In prisons there is place for all.. A new report from the Arab Network], Mada Misr, September 5, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/09/05/news/u/في-السجون-هناك-متسع-للجميع-تقرير-جدي/.
52 ‘Omar Sa‘id, “Maza Yakhdoth Dakhel al-Ikhwan al-Moslemiyn.. Moqarabun Wa ‘Adaa’ Yojibun” [What is happening inside the Muslim Brotherhood.. Affiliates and members answer], Mada Misr, June 8, 2015, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2015/06/08/feature/سياسة/ماذا-يحدث-داخل-الإخوان-المسلمين-مقربو/; Heba ‘Afifi, “Thawrat al-Ghalaba 11/11.. Inteshar Wasae‘ Yohiytoho al-Ghomud” [The revolution of the needy 11/11.. widespread mobilization surrounded by ambiguity], Mada Misr, November 6, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/11/06/feature/سياسة/ثورة-الغلابة-1111-انتشار-واسع-يحيطه-الغ/.
53 Mohamed Muwafi, “al-Qesa al-Kamela Wazir Mobarak Yosh‘el Intefadat al-Khobz Bel-Mohafazat” [The full story Mobarak’s minister ignites a bread uprising in the governorates], Misr al-‘Arabiya, March 7, 2017, http://www.masralarabia.com/اقتصاد/1378410-الخبز-؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟. .
54 “Haqiqat Isteqalat al-Ikhwan“ [The truth behind the Brotherhood’s resignations], al-Misriyyun, December 21, 2015, https://almesryoon.com/دفتر-أحوال-الوطن/838200-حقيقة-استقالات-الإخوان.
55 Mostafa Makhluf & Shaymaa’ al-Qaranshawi, “al-Idariya al-‘Olya Taqdi Be-‘Adam Jawaz Ihalat Da‘wa Hal Hezb al-Nur” [The supreme administrative court rules against dissolving the Nur Party], al-Misri al-Yum, July 5, 2015, http://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/768527.
56 Mahmud ‘Abbas, “Lemaza Ayad Hezb al-Nur al-Inqelab al-‘Askari Ded Morsi?” [Why did the Nur Party support the military coup against Morsi], Noon Post, October 24, 2015, http://www.noonpost.org/انقلاب-مصر/لماذا-أيد-حزب-النور-الانقلاب-العسكري-ضد-مرسي؟.
57 Nada al-Misri, “Lagnat al-Khamsin” [The committee of 50], Misriyyat, September 2, 2013, http://www.masreat.com/لجنة-الخمسين-تعديل-الدستور/.
58 Wa’el Thabet, “Hezb al-Nur Yo‘len Da‘amaho Lel-Sisi Fi al-Intekhabat al-Ri’asiya” [Nur Party announces its support for Sisi in the presidential elections], al-Badil, May 3, 2014, http://elbadil.com/2014/05/حزب-النور-يعلن-دعمه-للسيسي-في-الانتخاب/.
59 Hossam Bahgat, “Hakaza Intakhab al-Sisi barlamanoho” [Here is how Sisi elected his parliament], Mada Masr, March 8, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/03/08/feature/سياسة/هكذا-انتخب-السيسي-برلمانه/.
60 Khaled ‘Abdel Rasul et al, “al-Kharita al-Neha’iya Lel-Ahzab Wa al-Mostaqeliyn Taht al-Qoba” [The final chart of parties and independents in parliament], al-Watan, December 4, 2015, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/850811.
61 Hani Ramdan, “Majles al-Sha‘ab al-Misri 2012.. al-Tashkil Wa al-Maham“ [The Egyptian People’s Assembly 2012.. Composition and Mandate], BBC, January 23, 2013, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2012/01/120123_egypt_palt_hani; Do‘aa’ ‘Abdel Latif, “Hezb al-Nur.. Sefr al-Intekhabat Yoghayir al-Hesabat” [The Nur Party.. Election’s zero changes calculations], Al Jazeera, October 22, 2015, http://www.aljazeera.net/news/reportsandinterviews/2015/10/22/حزب-النور-المصري-عندما-ينتهي-التلون-بالفشل%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%81%D8%B4%D9%84.
62 Mohamed al-Sudani, “Admen Kolena Khaled Sa‘id Ya‘ud Ba‘d Ghiyab Wa Yotaleb Be-Tawhod Quwa al-Thawra” [Admin of Khaled Said’s Facebook page returns after absence and demands unity among the revolution’s forces], Misr al-‘Arabiya, May 20, 2015, http://www.masralarabia.com/سوشيال-ميديا/598231-أدمن-كلنا-خالد-سعيد-يعود-بعد-غياب-ويطالب-بتوحد-قوى-ثورة-يناير.
63 “al-Safaha al-Rasmiya” [Maspero’s Youth Union.. The official page], Itehad Shabab Maspiru, no date, accessed April 1, 2017, https://www.facebook.com/pg/Coptic.Masbero/about/?ref=page_internal; Dina ‘Ezzat, “Ra’is Itehad Shabab Maspiru Fi Hadith ‘Aan al-Muwatana al-Kamela” [President of the Maspero’s Youth Union in a conversation about equal citizenship], Shoruq, October 22, 2016, http://natega.shorouknews.com/news/view.aspx?cdate=22102016&id=5f960266-e6d2-467a-8df0-38e79c386957.
64 “4 A‘wam ‘Ala Majazret Maspiru Wa Lazal al-Motawaretiyn Fi Ghiyab Men al-‘Adala” [4 years since the Maspiro massacre and those implicated remain away from justice], Human Rights Monitor, October 9, 2015, http://humanrights-monitor.org/Posts/ViewLocale/18283#.WMdkCBhh3Vo.
65 ‘Alyaa’ Mosalam, “‘Aan Hob al-Hayat Wa Habs ‘Alaa’” [On loving life and Alaa Seif’s imprisonment], al-Horiyya Lel-Jeda‘an, Facebook, February 22, 2105, https://www.facebook.com/Al7oriallgd3an/photos/a.110216819090186.15443.110174469094421/650145251764004/?type=1&theater.
66 Ahmed al-Fakharani, “Misr: Hamlat al-Horiyya Lel-Jeda‘an.. La Tuwqef al-I‘teqalat” [Egypt: Freedom for the Brave campaign does not stop arrests], al-Modon, February 8, 2014, http://www.almodon.com/arabworld/2014/2/8/مصر-حملة-الحرية-للجدعان-لا-توقف-الاعتقالات.
67 Najwa Mostafa, “al-Horiyya Lel-Jeda‘an.. Hamla Le-Noshataa’ Misriyyin Lel-Motalba Bel-Ifraj ‘Aan al-Mo‘taqliyn al-Siyasiyyin” [Freedom for the Brave.. A campign by Egyptian activists to demand the release of political prisoners], Ra’ay al-Yum, February 6, 2014, http://www.raialyoum.com/?p=50160.
68 Mahmud Hassuna, “al-Horiyya Lel-Jeda‘an: 163 Halat Ikhtefaa’ Qasri Wa Ihtejaz Dun Tahqiq Monzo Abril“ [Freedom for the Brave: 163 cases of forced disappearances and detentions without legal proceedings], al-Watan, June 8, 2015, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/746597.
69 Shaymaa’ Hamdi, “al-Horiyya Lel-Jeda‘an Tabdaa’ Hamlat ‘Ide‘amuhom’ Lel-Ifraj ‘Aan al-Mo‘taqliyn al-Siyasiyyin” [Freedom for the Brave launches “Support Them” campaign to demand the release of political prisoners], al-Badil, Feburary 25, 2014, http://elbadil.com/2014/02/الحرية-للجدعان-تبدأ-حملة-ادعموهم-للإ/.
70 “al-Horiyya Lel-Jeda‘an Totleq Hamlat ‘La Lel-Habs al-Inferadi’” [Freedom for the Brave launches “No to Solitary Confinement” campaign], Arabic Network for Human Rights Information, June 9, 2016, http://anhri.net/?p=166611.
71 Shaymaa’ Hamdi, “al-Horiyya Lel-Jeda‘an Tabdaa’ Hamlat ‘Ide‘amuhom’ Lel-Ifraj ‘Aan al-Mo‘taqliyn al-Siyasiyyin” [Freedom for the Brave launches “Support Them” campaign to demand the release of political prisoners], al-Badil, Feburary 25, 2014, http://elbadil.com/2014/02/الحرية-للجدعان-تبدأ-حملة-ادعموهم-للإ/; “al-Horiyya Lel-Jeda‘an: Zanazin al-Zolm Habsa al-‘Eid” [Freedom for the Brave: Prison cells full of injustice undermine religious feast’s happiness], al-Misriyyun, October 3, 2014, https://almesryoon.com/دفتر-أحوال-الوطن/568347-الحرية-للجدعان-زنازين-الظلم-حابسة-العيد.
72 Amr Hamzawy, “Legislating Authoritarianism: Egypt’s New Era of Repression,” Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, March 16, 2017, http://carnegieendowment.org/2017/03/16/legislating-authoritarianism-egypt-s-new-era-of-repression-pub-68285.
73 Ahmed Jamal Ziyada, “Waqaa’e‘ ‘Omumiyat al-Karama’” [Proceedings of the ‘dignity’s general assembly’], Mada Misr, Feburary 12, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/02/12/feature/سياسة/وقائع-عمومية-الكرامة-عناد-الداخلية-ي/; Biysan Kassab, “Ayna Taqef al-Neqabat al-Mehaniya Men Azmat al-Sahafiyyin?” [Where do professional associations stand with regard to the crisis of the Syndicate of Journalists?], Mada Misr, May 3, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/05/03/feature/سياسة/أين-تقف-النقابات-المهنية-من-أزمة-الصحف/.
74 “Sera‘ al-Nezam Wa al-Neqabat al-Mehaniya Fi Misr; Men Mobarak Ila al-Sisi” [The conflict between the regime and professional associations in Egypt: From Mobarak to Sisi], Sasa Post, Feburary 12, 2016, https://www.sasapost.com/the-conflict-between-egyptian-regime-and-syndicates/; “al-Ikhwan Wa al-Neqabat Fi ‘Ahd Mobarak” [The Brotherhood and the professional associations during Mobarak’s Era], Ikhwan Wiki, no date, accessed on March 30, 2017, http://www.ikhwanwiki.com/index.php?title=الإخوان_والنقابات_فى_عهد_مبارك.
75 Mahiytab ‘Abdel Fattah, “Mostashfa al-Matariya Waqud Intefadat al-Atebaa’” [Matariya hospital fuels the doctors’ uprising], al-Badil, Feburary 13, 2016, http://elbadil.com/2016/02/مستشفي-المطرية-وقود-انتفاضة-الأطبا/.
76 And per the narrative of the doctors’ syndicate, one of the police officers assaulted Ahmed Mahmud el-Tayeb, the resident doctor in the surgery department in the Matariya hospital after the doctor refused the request of the police officer to prove unreal injuries in his medical report. As a result, the police officer attacked the doctor and the administrative deputy at the hospital with the help of another police officer that was with him, and then they took them over to the Matariya police station to continue abusing and assaulting their dignity. However, the police officer has released them and returned them to the hospital. See Ahmed Mohamed ‘Abdel Baset, “Bel-Sewar: Atebaa’ Misr.. Men Yokhayet Jirahahom?” [In pictures: Egypt’s doctors.. who can heel their injuries?], al-Watan, February 12, 2016, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/969748.
77 Ibid.
78 Ibid.
79 “Neqabat Atebaa’ Misr Tad‘u A‘daa’eha Le-Hodur al-Jam‘iya al-‘Omumiya al-Tare’a al-Jome‘a 12 Febrayir” [Egyptian Doctors’ Syndicate calls its members to attend the exceptional general assembly on February 12], Egyptian Medical Syndicate, February 5, 2016, http://www.ems.org.eg/our_news/details/3895.
80 “Jame‘ Tarikhi Hashed Lel-Atebaa’ Fi Misr Ihtijajan ‘Ala I‘tedaa’at al-Shorta ‘Aliyhom” [Historic assembly for doctors in Egypt protesting police attacks on them], BBC, Feburary 13, 2016, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2016/02/160212_egypt_doctors_protest.
81 Osama Ja‘fer, “Bel-Sewar: Waqafat al-Karama Fi Jamie‘ Mostashfayat al-Jomhuriya” [In pictures: Dignity Rallies in all hospitals across the republic], Egyptian Medical Syndicate, Feburary 20, 2016, http://www.ems.org.eg/our_news/details/3956.
82 Mohamed Hussein, “Atebaa’ Misr Yaqudun Akbar Muwajaha ‘Ghayr Siyasiya’ Ded al-Solta Monzo 2013” [Egypt’s doctors lead the largest non-political confrontation with the government since 2013], Huffington Post Arabic, February 13, 2016, http://www.huffpostarabi.com/2016/02/13/story_n_9221338.html.
83 Ahmed Ghonim, “Ra’is al-Wuzaraa’ Yuwajeh Be-Mo‘aqabat al-Modanin Fi Azmat Atebaa’ al-Matariya” [The prime minister orders the punishment of those accused in the Matariya doctors’ crisis], al-Watan, February 12, 2016, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/969859.
84 “Ra’is al-Wuzaraa’: Sa-Ijtame‘ Ma‘a al-Atebaa’ Wa Wazir al-Seha Qariban Le-Hal Azmat al-Matariya” [The prime minister: I will meet with the doctors and the minister of health soon to solve the Matariya crisis], al-Watan, February 15, 2016, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/974992.
85 A phone interview conducted by Nihad Abboud, the author’s research assistant, with Dr. Mai Hassan Khalil, a member of the elected board of the Egyptian Doctors’ Syndicate, Fall 2016.
86 “Taa’jil Mohakamet 9 Omanaa’ Shorta Fi Ahdath Mostashfa al-Matariya Ila 20 Sebtamber” [Adjournment of court proceedings against 9 policemen implicated in the Matariya hospital’s incidient to September 20], Aswat Misriya, July 19, 2016, http://www.aswatmasriya.com/news/details/65735.
87 For example, the administrative judiciary issued in the fall of 2015 a ruling that entails the legitimacy of the doctors who work in the public hospitals and facilities to have an “infection compensation” of 1,000 EGP per month. However, the government abstained from carrying out and implementing the decision, and it stretched the negotiations with the doctors’ syndicate until the latter decided to end the negotiations in the fall of 2016. See Hadir al-Khodari, “Neqabet al-Atebaa’ Tuwqef Mofawadat Badl al-‘Adawa Ma‘a al-Hokuma” [Doctors’ Syndicate stops negotiations with the government regarding the infection compensation], Aswat Misriya, October 17, 2016, http://www.aswatmasriya.com/news/details/68875.
88 Raniya ‘Omar, “Tashwih Sowrat al-Atebaa’.. Jadid al-I‘lam al-Misri” [Defamation of doctors.. a new trend in the Egyptian media], al-‘Arabi al-Jadid, February 19, 2016, https://www.alaraby.co.uk/medianews/2016/2/19/تشويه-صورة-الأطباء-جديد-الإعلام-المصري.
89 Mahiytab ‘Abdel Fattah, “Ghadab Be-Sabab al-Tahqiq Ma‘a Mona Mina.. Wa Atebaa’ Yuqarerun al-I‘tesam” [Anger because of interrogating Mona Mina.. Doctors decide to perform a sit-in], al-Badil, November 3, 2016, http://elbadil.com/2016/11/30/غضب-بسبب-التحقيق-مع-منى-مينا-وأطباء/.
90 “Dr. Hazem Hosni: al-Ta‘atof Ma‘a al-Atebaa’ Fi Waqfatohom Ded Taghuwel Nezam al-Sisi Yu’aked Wa‘ai al-Misriyyin” [Dr. Hazem Hosni: Solidarity with doctors in their standoff with the aggressive Sisi regime proves awareness of Egyptians], al-Taqrir al-Misri, February 13, 2016, http://www.egyrep.com/د-حازم-حسني-التعاطف-مع-الأطباء-في-وقفت/; “Mohame: Hefz al-Tahqiqat Ma‘a Mona Mina Fi Itehameha Be-Nashr Akhbar Kazeba” [Lawyer: Interrogations of Mona Mina in the accusation of propagating false news are stopped], Aswat Misriya, March 12, 2017, http://www.aswatmasriya.com/news/details/73824.
91 “China, Egypt Imprison Record Numbers of Journalists,” Committee to Protect Journalists, December 15, 2015, https://www.cpj.org/reports/2015/12/china-egypt-imprison-record-numbers-of-journalists-jail.php; “2016 Prison Census: 259 Journalists Jailed Worldwide,” Committee to Protect Journalists, December 1, 2016, https://cpj.org/mideast/egypt/.
92 “Taqrir Dawli: Misr Thani Aswaa’ Dawla Fi Habs al-Sahafiyyin Bel-‘Alam” [International report: Egypt is the second worst country in jailing journalists worldwide], Aswat Misriya, December 15, 2015, http://www.aswatmasriya.com/news/details/52625 .
93 “‘Fi Joma‘at al-Ard’.. al-Qabd ‘Ala Motazahiriyn Fi al-Isma‘iliya Wa al-Mansura.. Wa Tazahorat Mohit al-Sahafiyyin Mostamera Raghm al-Tadiyyiq al-Amni” [On the ‘Land Friday’.. Arrests of demonstrators in Isma‘iliya and Mansura.. Demonstration around the Syndicate of Journalists continues despite security restrictions], Mada Misr, April 15, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/04/15/news/u/في-جمعة-الأرض-القبض-على-متظاهرين-في-ال/.
94 “Bel-Asmaa’.. al-Mosharekun Fi Mozaharat ‘al-Ard Hiya al-‘Ard’” [In names.. Participants in the ‘Land is Honor’ demonstrations], al-Misriyyun, April 14, 2016, https://almesryoon.com/دفتر-أحوال-الوطن/876448-بالأسماء-المشاركون-في-مظاهرات-«الأرض-هي-العرض».
95 “‘Joma‘at al-Ard’ Tatasader Twitter Fi al-‘Alam” [‘Land is Honor’ Friday leads twitter feeds worldwide], CNN, April 15, 2016, http://arabic.cnn.com/middleeast/2016/04/15/egypt-tiran-sanafir-25th-january.
96 “al-Amn Ya‘taqel al-‘Asharat Wa Yofareq Tazahorat ‘al-Ard’ Bel-Khatush Wa al-Ghaz” [Security arrests dozens and disbands ‘Land is Honor’ demonstrations using rubber bullets and teargas], Mada Misr, April 25, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/04/25/feature/سياسة/الأمن-يعتقل-العشرات-ويُفرق-تظاهرات-ال/.
97 “Jabhat al-Defae‘ ‘Aan Motazahiri al-Ard; Mo‘taqaluw Ihtejajat Tiran Wa Sanafir 100 Motazahirin” [Front for the defense of land demonstrators: 100 arrested in Tiran and Sanafir protests], al-Qods al-‘Arabi, April 15, 2016, http://www.alquds.co.uk/?p=517028.
98 Suzan ‘Abdel Ghani, “Nanshor Asmaa’ 230 Mo‘taqalan Men Motazahiri 25 Abril” [We publish the names of 230 arrested demonstrators on April 25], al-Bedaya, April 27, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/04/27/112063; “Egypt: Fearing Protests, Police Arrest Hundreds. Journalists, Lawyers Among Those Apprehended,” Human Rights Watch, April 27, 2016, https://www.hrw.org/news/2016/04/27/egypt-fearing-protests-police-arrest-hundreds.
99 Yanayir Gate, http://yanairgate.net/; “Mahmud al-Saqqa Le-CNN: al-Nezam Yu’adeb Thawrat Yanayir” [Mahmud al-Saqqa to CNN: The regime disciplines the January Revolution], CNN, October 2, 2016, http://arabic.cnn.com/middleeast/2016/10/02/egypt-mahloud-saqqa-interview.
100 Ibrahim al-Hawari, “Masdar Amni: ‘Amr Badr Wa Mahmud al-Saqqa Sader Lahoma Amr Dabt Wa Ihedar Be-Tohmat al-Tajamhor Wa al-Tahrid ‘Ala al-Tazahor” [Security source: An arrest warrant has been issued against Amr Badr and Mahmud al-Saqqa with unlawful assembly and inciting to demonstrate charges], Sada al-Balad, May 1, 2016, http://www.elbalad.news/2174518.
101 Mohamed ‘Atef, “‘Amr Badr Wa al-Saqqa Yadkholan Fi I‘tesam Maftuh Be-Neqabat al-Sahafiyyin I‘teradan ‘Ala Dabtehem Wa Ihdarehem Wa Iqteham Manazelehem” [Amr badr and al-Saqqa begin an open sit-in in the journalists’ syndicate protesting their arrest warrant and the storming of their homes], al-Bedaya, April 30, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/04/30/112210.
102 “Le-Aual Mara Fi Tariykh al-Neqaba Quwat al-Amn Taqtahem Neqabat al-Sahafiyyin Wa Tolqi al-Qabd ‘Ala Badr Wa al-Saqqa” [For the first time in the syndicate’s history security forces storm the journalists’ syndicate and arrest Badr and al-Saqqa], Misr al-‘Arabiya, May 1, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/الحياة-السياسية/1040213-قوات-الأمن-تقتحم-نقابة-الصحفيين-وتُلقي-القبض-على-بدر-والسقا.
103 Samar Medhat, “Fi Zekra Ta’sisaha.. 5 Mahtat Hama Be-Tariykh Neqabat al-Sahafiyyin” [On its anniversary.. 5 significant milestones in the history of the Syndicate of Journalists], al-Wafd, March 31, 2016, https://alwafd.org/أخبار-وتقارير/1103331-في-ذكرى-تأسيسها-5-محطات-هامة-بتاريخ-«نقابة-الصحفيين».
104 Mohamed Qasem, “Bel-Sewar.. Tafasil Iteham ‘Amr Badr Wa Mahmud al-Saqqa Bel-Taharid ‘Ala al-Tazahor” [In pictures.. Details of accusing Amr Badr and Mahmud al-Saqqa of inciting demonstrations], al-Yum al-Sabae‘, May 2, 2016, http://www.youm7.com/story/2016/5/2/بالصور-تفاصيل-اتهام-عمرو-بدر-ومحمود-السقا-بالتحريض-على-التظاهر/2701144.
105 Samir Hosni, “Qalash: al-Amn Iqtaham Neqabat al-Sahafiyyin Lel-Mara al-Aula Bel-Tariykh Wa Onashed al-Ra’is al-Tadkhol” [Qalash: security forces stormed the journalists’ syndicate for the first time ever and I call on the president to interfere], al-Yum al-Sabae‘, May 1, 2016, http://www.youm7.com/story/2016/5/1/قلاش-الأمن-اقتحم-نقابة-الصحفيين-للمرة-الأولى-بالتاريخ-وأناشد-الرئيس/2699928.
106 Yara Saleh, “Jamal ‘Abdel Rahim Yotaleb Be-‘Azl Wazir al-Dakheliya Wa Yohamel al-Sisi Mas’uwliyat Iqteham al-Sahafiyyin” [Jamal Abdel Rahim demands the dismissal of the minister of the interior and blames Sisi for the storming of the journalists’ syndicate], al-Bedaya, May 2, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/05/02/112357.
107 ‘Abdallah Bedair, “Khaled al-Balshi: Iqteham Neqabat al-Sahafiyyin I‘tedaa’ Ghashem Wa Ghayr Masbuq” [Khaled el-Balshy: Storming the journalists’ syndicate is a violent and unprecedented aggression], Misr al-‘Arabiya, May 1, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/سوشيال-ميديا/1040291-خالد-البلشي-اقتحام-نقابة-الصحفيين-اعتداء-غاشم-وغير-مسبوق .
108 Ingy Taha, “Mahmud Kamel Mo‘leqqan ‘Ala Iqteham al-Sahafiyyin: al-Dakheliya Tasir Bel-Watan Le-Hafat al-Hawiya” [Mahmud Kamel commenting on the storming of the journalists’ syndicate: The ministry of the interior pushes the nation to the brink], al-Wafd, May 1, 2016, https://alwafd.org/أخبار-وتقارير/1157777-محمود-كامل-معلقًا-على-اقتحام-الصحفيين-الداخلية-تسير-بالوطن-لحافة-الهاوية.
109 Mohamed Jamal, “Iqalat Wazir al-Dakheliya Wa Taswid al-Sohof.. Mataleb Neqabat al-Sahafiyyin Ba‘d Istebahat Maqaraha Men Qebl al-Amn” [Dismissing the minister of the interior and blackening of newspapers.. demands of the journalists’ syndicate after security forces stormed its premises], Huffington Post Arabic, May 2, 2016, http://www.huffpostarabi.com/2016/05/02/story_n_9818926.html.
110 Mohamed al-Sayyid, “Nanshor Qararat al-Jam‘iya al-‘Omumiya Lel-Sahafiyyin Radan ‘Ala Azmat Iqteham al-Neqaba” [We publish the decisions of the general assembly of the journalists’ syndicate in response to the crisis following the storming of the syndicate], al-Yum al-Sabae‘, May 4, 2016, http://www.youm7.com/story/2016/5/4/ننشر-قرارات-الجمعية-العمومية-للصحفيين-ردا-على-أزمة-اقتحام-النقابة/2703692.
111 Wagih al-Saqqar et al, “Kol al-Ajyal Wa al-Itejahat Fi Ijtemae‘ ‘al-Osra al-Sahafiya’ Bel-Ahram” [All generations and directions in attendance in the ‘Press Family’ meeting in Ahram], Ahram, May 9, 2016, http://www.ahram.org.eg/NewsPrint/510614.aspx.
112 “Bayan Ijtemae‘ al-Osra al-Sahafiya Bel-Ahram” [Statement of the ‘Press Family’ meeting in Ahram], Ahram, May 8, 2016, http://shabab.ahram.org.eg/News/48053.aspx .
113 Mina Ghali, “Isted‘aa’ Qalash Wa al-Balshi Wa ‘Abdel Rahim Lel-Tahqiq Fi Waqe‘at ‘Badr Wa al-Saqqa’ al-Ahad” [Citing Qalash, Balshy, and Abdel Rahim for interrogation in the incident of ‘Badr and al-Saqqa’ on Sunday], al-Misri al-Yum, May 28, 2016, http://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/955793.
114 “al-Neyaba Tohil Naqib al-Sahafiyyin al-Misriyyin Wa Ithnayn Men al-A‘daa’ Le-Mohakama ‘Ajela” [Prosecution refers head of the elected board of the journalists’ syndicate and two members to an expedited trial], BBC, May 31, 2016, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/worldnews/2016/05/160530_egypt_journalists_detention.
115 “Mahkama Misriya Taqdi Be-Habs Naqib al-Sahafiyyin Wa ‘Odawin Fi Majles al-Neqaba Le-‘Amayn” [An Egyptian court sentences head of the elected board of the journalists’ syndicate and two members to two years in imprisonment], BBC, November 19, 2016, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast-38038271.
116 Mo‘taz Shams al-Din, “Tazamonan Ma‘a Hadith al-Sisi ‘Aan Horiyyat al-I‘lam.. Akbar Hamlat Dabt Wa Ihedar Lel-Sahafiyyin Wa Modahamt 6 Maqarat I‘lamiya Qabl 11 Nufamber” [Coinciding with Sisi’s talk about media freedom.. Biggest campaigh to arrest journalists and storming of 6 media facilities prior to November 11], Huffington Post Arabic, October 27, 2016, http://www.huffpostarabi.com/2016/10/27/story_n_12669428.html .
117 ‘Abdel Rahman Riyad, “al-Haraka al-Tolabiya: Ghiyab al-Qadiya Wa Aulawiyat al-Sera‘” [The student movement: Absent cause and struggle priorities], Mada Misr, March 18, 2015, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2015/03/18/opinion/u/الحركة-الطلابية-غياب-القضية-وأولويات/.
118 Mohamed Hamama, “‘Alamat Istefham Hawl Ta‘dilat ‘La’ehat al-Itehadat al-Tolabiya” [Questions marks about the amendments of the bylaws of student unions], Mada Misr, October 20, 2015, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/sections/politics/علامات-استفهام-حول-تعديلات-لائحة-الاتحادات-الطلابية.
119 “1677 Ihtejaj Tolabi Khelal al-Fasal al-Derasi al-Aual Le-‘Aam 2013-2014” [1677 student protests during the first semester of the academic year 2013-2014], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 30, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.ch/2014/03/1677-2013-2014_31.html.
120 According to the Democracy Index Institution, the number of students who have been deprived of their freedom reached 1,326 within the first semester of the 2013–2014 academic year and dozens were killed due to the excessive force of the security apparatuses. See: Ibid.
121 Sherihan Ashraf, “‘Audat al-Dabtiya al-Qada’iya Dakhel al-Jame‘at Tonzer Be-Qame‘ al-Fasaa’el al-Siyasiya al-Tolabiya” [Legalizing arresting students on campuses again threatens to repress all student political groupings], al-Badil, September 5, 2013, http://elbadil.com/2013/09/عودة-الضبطية-القضائية-داخل-الجامعا/.
122 “Hokm al-Mahkama al-Ideariya al-‘Olya Fi Qadiyat al-Haras al-Jame‘i” [the ruling of the supreme administrative court in the university guard’s case], Mu’asaset Horiyyat al-Fekr Wa al-Ta‘bir, October 26, 2010, http://afteegypt.org/academic_freedom/2010/10/26/177-afteegypt.html.
123 In the 2014–2015 academic year, Egyptian universities signed contracts with private security companies to carry out security business on campuses, which has resulted in some of the violent clashes between the protesting students and the private security companies’ personnel. Bassant Rabie‘, “Mo‘dalat Taa’min al-Haram al-Jame‘i” [The dilemma of security university campuses], Mada Misr, December 3, 2014, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2014/12/03/feature/سياسة/معضلة-تأمين-الحرم-الجامعي/.
124 Hesham al-Miyani, “Qarar Jomhuri Be-Tamkin Ru’asaa’ al-Jame‘at Men Tawqie‘ ‘Oqubat al-Fasl ‘Ala al-Tolab al-Lazina Yomaresun A‘malan Takhriyebiya” [Presidential decree to empower university presidents to dismiss students involved in destructive actions], Ahram, February 18, 2014, http://gate.ahram.org.eg/News/458004.aspx; Do‘aa’ ‘Adel, “Ta‘liqan ‘Ala Qanun al-Jame‘at.. ‘Omadaa’ Koliyat: Yahtaj Tawdihat Wa Men Haq al-Tolab al-Tazalom Ded Qararat al-Jame‘a” [Commeninting on the universities’ law.. Deans of different faculties: It warrants explanations and students have the right to appeal university decisions], al-Watan, February 19, 2014, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/421336; ‘Abdel Rahman Mosharaf, “Qanun Tanzim al-Jame‘at Yatasada Lel-Mokharebin Men Tolab al-Irhabiya Ma‘a Beda’ al-‘Aam al-Dirasi” [Universities’ law confronts rogue students of the terrorist Muslim Brotherhood at the beginning of the new academic year], al-Yum al-Sabae‘, October 11, 2014, http://www.youm7.com/story/2014/10/11/قانون-تنظيم-الجامعات-يتصدى-للمخربين-من-طلاب-الإرهابية-مع-بدء/1901388.
125 Abdel Rahman Mosharaf, “Qanun Tanzim al-Jame‘at Yatasada Lel-Mokharebin Men Tolab al-Irhabiya Ma‘a Beda’ al-‘Aam al-Dirasi” [Universities’ law confronts rogue students of the terrorist Muslim Brotherhood at the beginning of the new academic year], al-Yum al-Sabae‘, October 11, 2014, http://www.youm7.com/story/2014/10/11/قانون-تنظيم-الجامعات-يتصدى-للمخربين-من-طلاب-الإرهابية-مع-بدء/1901388.
126 “1677 Ihtejaj Tolabi Khelal al-Fasal al-Derasi al-Aual Le-‘Aam 2013-2014,” Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya.
127 ‘Ali Jamal al-Din, “Misr: Tolab Mafsulun Men al-Jame‘at Yakhshun Dayae‘ Mostaqbalehem” [Egypt: Students dismissed from universities fear a future career loss], BBC Arabic, November 20, 2014, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2014/11/141120_egypt_expelled_students.
128 “1677 Ihtejaj Tolabi Khelal al-Fasal al-Derasi al-Aual Le-‘Aam 2013-2014,” Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya.
129 “572 Ihtejaj Tolabi Khelal al-Fasal al-Derasi al-Aual 2014-2015” [572 student protests during the first semester of the academic year 2014-2015], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 30, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.ch/2015/04/572-2014-2015.html.
130 Besha Majed & Mai Shams al-Din, “30 Yunyu Ba‘d 3 Sanawat: al-Dawla Wa al-Jame‘at - Mohawalat al-Dawla Le-‘Adam Tasyis al-Jame‘at Tantahi Bel-Fashal” [June 30, 3 years on, the state and the universities – attempts by the state to depoliticize the univerisites are failing], Mada Misr, June 30, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/06/30/feature/سياسة/30-يونيو-بعد-3-سنوات-الدولة-والجامعات/.
131 Mohamed ‘Abdel Salam, “Man Yaqtol al-Tolab Fi al-Jame‘at al-Misriya?” [Who is killing students in Egyptian universities?], al-‘Arabi al-Jadid, August 6, 2015, https://www.alaraby.co.uk/supplementyouth/2015/8/6/من-يقتل-الطلاب-في-الجامعات-المصرية-.
132 “572 Ihtejaj Tolabi Khelal al-Fasal al-Derasi al-Aual 2014-2015,” Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya.
133 “Haraka ‘Ala Istehiyaa’ Wa Intehakat Mostamera.. Taqrir Hawl al-‘Aam al-Dirasi 2015/2016” [Limited movement and sustained violations.. A report about the academic year 2015-2016], Mu’asaset Horiyyat al-Fekr Wa al-Ta‘bir, August 16, 2016, http://afteegypt.org/academic_freedom/2016/08/16/12390-afteegypt.html.
134 Ibid.
135 Ibid.
136 The student unions’ bylaws, which was amended by the government of former president Morsi in 2012, was frozen after the coup in 2013, and the student union elections did not take place in the 2013–2014 and 2014–2015 academic years. See Islam Salah al-Din, “al-Itehadat al-Tolabiya.. Tariykh Men Mosadamat al-Hokam” [Student unions.. A history of confrontation with Egypt’s rulers], Shafaf, October 22, 2015, http://www.shafaff.com/article/9680.
137 Mohamed Hamama, “‘Alamat Istefham Hawl Ta‘dilat ‘La’ehat al-Itehadat al-Tolabiya” [Questions marks about the amendments of the bylaws of student unions], Mada Misr, October 20, 2015, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/sections/politics/علامات-استفهام-حول-تعديلات-لائحة-الاتحادات-الطلابية.
138 Ibid.
139 Mohamed Metwalli, “Nanshor al-Nataa’ej al-Kamela Le-Intekhabat al-Itehadat al-Tolab Fi al-Jame‘at” [We publish the complete results of student unions’ elections in universities], Misr al-‘Arabiya, November 17, 2015, http://www.masralarabia.com/شباب-وجامعات/796683-ننشر-النتائج-الكاملة-لانتخابات-اتحادات-الطلاب-في-الجامعات.
140 “‘Kasr al-Tawq’.. Kayf Istata‘a Tolab Mo‘aredun al-Fawz Fi al-Intekhabat al-Tolabiya?” [‘Breaking the siege’.. How opposition students managed to win student elections?], Mu’asaset Horiyyat al-Fekr Wa al-Ta‘bir, April 4, 2016, http://afteegypt.org/uncategorized/2016/04/04/12036-afteegypt.html; Mai Shams al-Din, “Fi Intekhabat Itehadat al-Tolab Bel-Jame‘at.. al-Siyasa Tahtader” [In student unions elections in universities.. politics is dying], Mada Misr, November 11, 2015, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2015/11/11/feature/سياسة/في-انتخابات-اتحادات-الطلاب-بالجامعات/.
141 “‘Abdallah Anwar Ra’is Itehad Tolab Misr” [Abdallah Anwar President of Egypt’s Student Union], Shababik, no date, accessed on March 30, 2017, http://shbabbek.com/SH-27101.
142 “Fawz al-Taleb ‘Amr al-Helew Be-Manseb Amin Itehad Tolab Jame‘at Tanta” [Student Amr al-Helew wins vice-chairmanship of the student union in Tanta University], Shababik, no date, accessed on March 30, 2017, http://shbabbek.com/SH-21846; “‘Abdallah Anwar Ra’is Itehad Tolab Misr” [Abdallah Anwar President of Egypt’s Student Union], Shababik, no date, accessed on March 30, 2017, http://shbabbek.com/SH-27101.
143 Mai Shams al-Din, “Fi Intekhabat Itehadat al-Tolab Bel-Jame‘at.. al-Siyasa Tahtader” [In student unions elections in universities.. politics is dying], Mada Misr, November 11, 2015, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2015/11/11/feature/سياسة/في-انتخابات-اتحادات-الطلاب-بالجامعات/.
144 Yussef Mohamed, “al-Shihi: Itehad Tolab Misr Ghayr Mo‘taraf Behi Ila Fi Hazehi al-Hala” [minister of higher education al-Shihi: Egypt’s Student Union will not be recognized except under one condition], Dot Misr, December 14, 2015, http://www.dotmsr.com/details/الشيحي-اتحاد-طلاب-مصر-غير-معترف-به-إلا-في-هذه-الحالة.
145 Wa’el Rabie‘I & Ahmed Hosni, “Monzamat Hoquqiya Todin Ilghaa’ Natijat Intekhabat Ra’is Itehad Tolab Misr Wa Na’ebehe” [Rights organization condemn the annulling of the results of electing the chairman and vice-chariman of Egypt’s student union], al-Yum al-Sabae‘, December 28, 2016, http://www.youm7.com/story/2015/12/28/منظمات-حقوقية-تدين-إلغاء-نتيجة-انتخابات-رئيس-اتحاد-طلاب-مصر/2512483.
146 “Haraka ‘Ala Istehiyaa’ Wa Intehakat Mostamera.. Taqrir Hawl al-‘Aam al-Dirasi 2015/2016” [Limited movement and sustained violations.. A report about the academic year 2015-2016], Mu’asaset Horiyyat al-Fekr Wa al-Ta‘bir, August 16, 2016, http://afteegypt.org/academic_freedom/2016/08/16/12390-afteegypt.html.
147 Yara Saleh, “Ha’ulaa’ Dafa‘u Thamn al-Defae‘ ‘Aan Tiran Wa Sanafir” [Those paid the price for defending Tiran and Sanafir], al-Bedaya, April 22, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/04/22/111666; Besha Majed & Mai Shams al-Din, “30 Yunyu Ba‘d 3 Sanawat: al-Dawla Wa al-Jame‘at - Mohawalat al-Dawla Le-‘Adam Tasyis al-Jame‘at Tantahi Bel-Fashal” [June 30, 3 years on, the state and the universities – attempts by the state to depoliticize the univerisites are failing], Mada Misr, June 30, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/06/30/feature/سياسة/30-يونيو-بعد-3-سنوات-الدولة-والجامعات/.
148 Ahmed Abdalla, The Student Movement and National Politics in Egypt, 1923-1973 (Cairo: American University Press, 2008).
149 ‘Abdel Rahman Naser, “al-Haraka al-Tolabiya Fi Misr Monzo al-Qarn al-Madi” [Student Movement in Egypt since the last century], Sasa Post, October 18, 2014, https://www.sasapost.com/the-student-movement-in-egypt-since-the-last-century/; Mohamed ‘Atef, “al-Haraka al-Tolabiya al-Misriya – al-Sedam Bayn al-Talaba Wa al-Solta” [The Egyptian student movement – The clash between the students and the government], Sasa Post, March 6, 2016, https://www.sasapost.com/opinion/the-student-movement-egyptian/.
150 Lina ‘Atallah, “Misr 2015: Kuz al-Mahba Itkharam” [Egypt 2015: Accord coming to an end], Mada Misr, December 31, 2015, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2015/12/31/feature/سياسة/مصر-2015-كوز-المحبة-اتخرم/; Ahmed Mohamed Mostafa & Hayat al-Ya‘qubi, “al-Dawr al-Siyasi Lel-Neqabat al-‘Omaliya al-‘Arabiya Fi Zel Thawarat al-Rabie‘ al-‘Arabi” [The political role of Arab labor unions amind the revolutions of the Arab spring], Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, 2015, http://festunis.org/media/2016/pdf/Le_role_politique_des_syndicats-en_arabe.pdf.
151 For the Egyptian Center for Economic and Social Rights (al-Markaz al-Misri Lel-Hoquq al-Iqtesadiya Wa al-Ijtema‘iya), see http://ecesr.org and for the Democracy Index Institution (Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya) see http://demometer.blogspot.com. Both pubslih periodic statistics for labor protests in Egypt and their qualitative and quantitative distribution.
152 “1117 Ihtejajan Lel-Motalaba Be-Hoquq al-‘Amal Khelal 2015” [1117 protests to demand labor rights during 2015], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 31, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.com/2016/01/1117-2015.html; “493 Ihtejajan ‘Omaliyan Khelal 4 Ashahor Yanayir – Abril 2016 Be-Motawaset 6 Ihtejajat Yumiyan Be-Ziyada 25% ‘Aan al-‘Aam al-Madi” [493 labor portests during the four months January – April 2016, an average of 6 daily protests, a 25% percent increase compared to the last year], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 31, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.com.eg/2016/04/493-4-6-25.html.
153 “Taqrir al-Ihtejajat al-‘Omaliya Le-‘Aam 2014” [Report on labor protests in 2014], al-Markaz al-Misri Lel-Hoquq al-Iqtesadiya Wa al-Ijtema‘iya, May 1, 2015, http://ecesr.org/2015/05/01/تقرير-الاحتجاجات-العمالية-لعام-2014/; “493 Ihtejajan ‘Omaliyan Khelal 4 Ashahor Yanayir – Abril 2016 Be-Motawaset 6 Ihtejajat Yumiyan Be-Ziyada 25% ‘Aan al-‘Aam al-Madi” [493 labor portests during the four months January – April 2016, an average of 6 daily protests, a 25% percent increase compared to the last year], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 31, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.com.eg/2016/04/493-4-6-25.html.
154 ‘Emad ‘Anan, “Fi Misr.. 1736 Ihtejajan Khelal ‘Aam Wa Tahazirat Men Ghadba Sha‘abiya Qadema” [In Egypt.. 1736 protests in a year and warnings that popular anger is risng], Noon Post, December 29, 2016, https://www.noonpost.net/content/15899.
155 “493 Ihtejajan ‘Omaliyan Khelal 4 Ashahor Yanayir – Abril 2016 Be-Motawaset 6 Ihtejajat Yumiyan Be-Ziyada 25% ‘Aan al-‘Aam al-Madi” [493 labor portests during the four months January – April 2016, an average of 6 daily protests, a 25% percent increase compared to the last year], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 31, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.com.eg/2016/04/493-4-6-25.html.
156 “1117 Ihtejajan Lel-Motalaba Be-Hoquq al-‘Amal Khelal 2015” [1117 protests to demand labor rights during 2015], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 31, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.com/2016/01/1117-2015.html.
157 In 2015, the number of workers and employees who were arrested because of protesting or calling for protests has almost reached seventy workers. See: “1117 Ihtejajan Lel-Motalaba Be-Hoquq al-‘Amal Khelal 2015” [1117 protests to demand labor rights during 2015], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 31, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.com/2016/01/1117-2015.html. Also, in 2015, more than eighty workers and employees have been arbitrarily dismissed in both the public and private sectors. See: Ibid.
158 Ibid.
159 Ibid.
160 “493 Ihtejajan ‘Omaliyan Khelal 4 Ashahor Yanayir – Abril 2016 Be-Motawaset 6 Ihtejajat Yumiyan Be-Ziyada 25% ‘Aan al-‘Aam al-Madi” [493 labor portests during the four months January – April 2016, an average of 6 daily protests, a 25% percent increase compared to the last year], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 31, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.com.eg/2016/04/493-4-6-25.html.
161 Nehal ‘Abdel Ra’uf, “Ihalat Da’wa Hal al-Neqabat al-Mostaqela Ila al-Dosturiya al-‘Olya” [Referral of the petition to dissolve independent unions to the Supreme Constitutional Court], Misr al-‘Arabiya, June 26, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/حوادث/1126944-إحالة-دعوى-حل-النقابات-المستقلة-إلى-الدستورية-العليا.
162 Hassan ‘Abdel Bar, “Qanun al-Neqabat al-‘Omaliya.. Geh Yekahalha ‘Ammaha” [Labor unions’ law.. dramatic deterioration instead of improvement], al-Badil, July 27, 2016, http://elbadil.com/2016/07/قانون-النقابات-العمالية-جه-يكحلها-عم/.
163 Ahmed al-Bora‘i, “Shar‘iyat al-Neqabat al-Mostaqela” [On the legitimacy of independent unions], Tahrir, May 23, 2015, http://www.tahrirnews.com/posts/197555/أحمد+البرعي+++النقابات+العمالية+++التضامن+الاجتماعي+++ويكيليكس+البرلمان+.
164 The Parliament approved the civil service law in October 2016. See: “al-Barlaman Yuwafeq Be-Shakl Nehaa’i ‘Ala Qanun al-Khedma al-Madaniya” [Parliament approves the civil service law], Aswat Misriya, October 4, 2016, http://www.aswatmasriya.com/news/details/68439.
165 “1117 Ihtejajan Lel-Motalaba Be-Hoquq al-‘Amal Khelal 2015” [1117 protests to demand labor rights during 2015], Mu’asaset Mu’asher al-Dimuqratiya, no date, accessed on March 31, 2017, http://demometer.blogspot.com/2016/01/1117-2015.html.
166 “al-Idrab al-Selmi Haq Le-Kol Muwaten” [Peaceful strike is a citizen’s right], Montada Qawanin al-Sharq, Feburary 18, 2015, http://www.eastlawsacademy.com/ForumPostView.aspx?I=118.
167 “Tadamonan Ma‘a ‘Omal ‘al-Iskandariya Lel-Ghazel Wa al-Nasij” [In solidarity with the workers of Alexandria Spinning and Weaving Company], al-Ishteraki, September 16, 2014, http://revsoc.me/statements/30886/.
168 “al-Idrabat al-‘Omaliya Tajtah al-Mohafazat” [Labor strikes storm governorates], al-Misriyyun, September 2, 2016, https://almesryoon.com/دفتر-أحوال-الوطن/920212-الإضرابات-العمالية-تجتاح-المحافظات.
169 Karem Yahaya, “Mehnat ‘Omal Tersanat al-Iskandariya” [The plight of the Alexandria Shipyard workers], al-Bedaya, July 19, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/07/19/116995.
170 Karem Yahaya, “Hona al-Iskandariya: al-Tabaqa al-‘Aamela.. Tazhab Ila al-Mahkama al-‘Askariya” [Here is Alexandria: The working class goes to the military court], al-Bedaya, July 13, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/07/13/116581.
171 “Taqrir: ‘Omal al-Tersana al-Bahariya Bayn Siyasat al-Tajuwie‘ Wa al-Mohakamat al-‘Askariya” [Report: The Alexandria Shipyard workers between starving policies and military trials], al-Markaz al-Misri Lel-Hoquq al-Iqtesadiya Wa al-Ijtema‘iya, October 18, 2016, http://ecesr.org/2016/10/18/تقرير-عمال-الترسانة-البحرية-بين-سياسا/.
172 Hadir al-Mahdawi, “al-Ta‘zib Wa al-Ikhtefaa’ al-Qasri Fi Misr.. Qeses Ma Waraa’ al-Arqam” [Torture and forced disappearance in Egypt.. the stories behind the numbers], Mada Misr, May 12, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/05/12/feature/سياسة/التعذيب-والاختفاء-في-مصر-قصص-ما-وراء-ا/; “Ahkam Bel-Sejn al-Moshadad Wa al-Habs Le-Dabet Wa 5 Omanaa’ Shorta Fi Maqtal Tal‘at Shabib Bel-Oqsor” [Imprisonment and detention sentences for a police officer and 5 policemen in the killing of Tal‘at Shabib in Luxor], Mada Misr, July 12, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/07/12/news/u/أحكام-بالسجن-المشدد-والحبس-لضابط-و5-أمن/.
173 The cases of outlaw killings and torture and violations that were most prominent in the media were linked to the police officers torturing the citizen ‘Emad al-Kabir in Giza Governorate (2006), the physical violence that led to the death of the Alexandrian Citizen Khaled Said (2010), and the detention and torturing and killing of the Alexandrian citizen Sayyid Belal (2011). See “Egypt: Bus Driver Raped by Police Forces Faces New Risk of Torture,” Human Rights Watch, January 12, 2007, https://www.hrw.org/ar/news/2007/01/12/231913; Shaher ‘Ayyad, “Khaled Sa‘id Men Daheyat Ta‘zib Ila Mofajer Thawrat al-Qasas Men al-Dakheliya” [Khaled Said from a torture victim to the catalyst of the revenge revolution against the ministry of the interior], al-Misri al-Yum, October 28, 2011, http://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/121627; Mohamed al-Sayyid, “Jenayat al-Iskandariya: al-Sejn 3 Sanawat Le-Dabet Sabeq Be-Amn al-Dawla Fi Qadiyat Ta‘zib Wa Qatl Sayyid Belal” [A criminal court in Alexandria: 3 years imprisonment for a former officer of the state security in the torturing and killing of Sayyid Belal], al-Bedaya, March 27, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/03/27/109851.
174 Khaled Hassan, “Hal Taa’yyid al-Qadaa’ Moraqabet al-Dakheliya Le-Mawaqae‘ al-Tawasul al-Ijtema‘i Qame‘ Lel-Horiyyat Am Hefaz ‘Ala al-Amn al-Qawmi?” [Is the judicial approval of security surveillance of social media an act of repressing freedoms or an act of preserving the country’s national security?], Al-Monitor, October 5, 2016, http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/ar/originals/2016/10/egypt-court-support-decision-monitor-social-media-facebook.html.
175 Ahmed ‘Abdo, “Bel-Sura.. ‘Mafish Haten Be-Yethakem’.. Gerafiti Be-Shawarae‘ al-Oqsor Ba‘d Itehamat Lel-Shorta Be-Tawarot Fi maqtal Muwaten” [In picture.. ‘no policeman on trial’.. Graffiti in the streets of Luxor after accusations of the police implication in the killing of a citizen], al-Bedaya, November 27, 2015, http://albedaiah.com/news/2015/11/27/101376.
176 Rajab Adam, “al-Sejn al-Moshadad 7 Sanawat Le-Dabet Be-Tohmat Qatl ‘Tala‘at Shabib’” [7 years imprisonment for an officer in the killing of ‘Tala‘at Shabib’], al-Watan, July 12, 2016, http://www.elwatannews.com/news/details/1257885; Ahmed ‘Abdo, “al-Sejn 7 Wa 3 Sanawat Le-Dabet Wa 5 Omanaa’ Fi Qatl Wa Ta‘zib ‘Tala‘at Shabib’ Wa Ilzam al-Dakheliya Be-Meliyun Wa Nasef Ta‘wid Muw’aqt” [7 and 3 year imprisonment sentences for an officer and 5 policemen in the killing and torture of ‘Tala‘at Shabib’ and obligating the ministry of the interior to one and a half million pounds temporary reparation], al-Bedaya, July 12, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/07/12/116488.
177 Ahmed Abu ‘Arab, “Hesar Modiriyyat Amn al-Qahira Ba‘d Maqtal Shab ‘Ala Yad Amin Shorta” [Siege of the Cairo Security Directorate after the killing of a young man by a policeman], Misr al-‘Arabiya, February 18, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/توك-شو/934243-فيديو-مواطنون-يحاصرون-مديرية-أمن-القاهرة-بعد-مقتل-شاب-على-يد-أمين-شرطة.
178 Basel Basha, “al-Me’aat Men Ahali al-Darb al-Ahmar Yatazaharun Amam Modiriyyat Amn al-Qahira Ba‘d Qatl Amin Shorta Saa’eq ‘Tuk Tuk’” [Hundreds of citizens from al-Darb al-Ahmar demonstrate in front of the Cairo Security Directorate after a policeman kills a rickshaw driver], al-Bedaya, February 18, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/02/18/107361.
179 “Hashtag al-Darb al-Ahmar Yajtah Twitter” [# al-Darb al-Ahmar storms Twitter], al-Misriyyun, February 19, 2016, https://almesryoon.com/story/857678/هاشتاج-الدرب-الأحمر-يجتاح-تويتر.
180 “Le-Aual Mara Fi I‘tezar ‘Alani.. Wazir al-Dakheliya al-Misri: Noqabel Raa’s Kol Muwatan Ta‘arad Lel-Isaa’a” [For the first time in a public apology.. The Egyptian Minsiter of the Interior: We apologize to every citizen who confronted bad treatment], Huffington Post Arabic, February 22, 2016, http://www.huffpostarabi.com/2016/02/22/---_n_9290214.html.
181 Mohamed Mostafa, “Beda’ Mohakamat Amin al-Shorta al-Motaham Be-Qatl Saa’eq al-Darb al-Ahmar” [The trial of the policeman implicated in the killing of al-Darb al-Ahmar’s driver begins], al-Wafd, March 5, 2016, https://alwafd.org/حوادث-وقضايا/1067710-بدء-محاكمة-أمين-الشرطة-المتهم-بقتل-سائق-الدرب-الأحمر.
183 “al-Mu’abad Le-Raqib Shorta Motaham Be-Qatl Saa’eq al-Darb al-Ahmar” [Life long imprisonment for the policeman implicated in the killing of al-Darb al-Ahmar’s driver], Aswat Misriya, April 2, 2016, http://www.aswatmasriya.com/news/details/61224.
183 “al-Ikhtefaa’ al-Qasri Jariyma Ded al-Insaniya Taqrir ‘Aan Halat al-Ikhtefaa’ al-Qasri Fi al-Nasf al-Aual Men 2015” [Forced disappearance is a crime against humanity, a report on the cases of forced disappearance in the first half of 2015], Human Rights Monitor, August 4, 2015, http://humanrights-monitor.org/Posts/ViewLocale/15262#.WMhcrBhh3R0; “Halat al-Qatl Kharej Itar al-Qanun Wa al-Ikhtefaa’ al-Qasri Fi Aghostos 2015.. 79 Halat Qatl Fi Misr Wathaqatha Human Rights Monitor Khelal Shahr Aghostos 2015” [Cases of outlaw killings and forced disappearances in August 2015.. 79 cases of killing in Egypt during August 2015 documented by Human Rights Monitor], Human Rights Monitor, September 4, 2015, http://humanrights-monitor.org/Posts/ViewLocale/16289#.WMhc7Rhh3R0.
184 Hadir al-Mahdawi, “al-Ta‘zib Wa al-Ikhtefaa’ al-Qasri Fi Misr.. Qeses Ma Waraa’ al-Arqam” [Torture and forced disappearance in Egypt.. the stories behind the numbers], Mada Misr, May 12, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/05/12/feature/سياسة/التعذيب-والاختفاء-في-مصر-قصص-ما-وراء-ا/; Markaz al-Nadim Le-Taa’hil Dahayya al-‘Onf Wa al-Ta‘zib (al-Nadeem Center for the Rehabilitation of Violence and Torture Victims), “Hasad al-Qahr Fi ‘Aam 2015” [Oppression balance sheet in 2015], Markaz al-Nadim Le-Taa’hil Dahayya al-‘Onf Wa al-Ta‘zib, January 10, 2016, http://www.alnadeem.org/content/حصاد-القهر-في-عام-2015.
185 On March 7, 2017, limited bread riots were reported in various Egyptian governorates. See: Hanan ‘Amer, “Intefadat al-Khobz Tasel al-Qahira” [The bread uprising reaches Cairo], Horiyya Post, March 7, 2017, http://horriapost.net/article/97566/عاجل----انتفاضة-الخبز-تصل-القاهرة--; “Misrawy Yarsod Intefadat al-Khobz Fi al-Mohafazat Wa Taklefataha al-Iqtesadiya (Taghtiya Khasa)” [Masrawy captures the bread uprising in the governorates and its economic cost (special coverage)], Misrawy, March 7, 2017, http://www.masrawy.com/News/News_Reports/details/2017/3/7/1039372/مصراوي-يرصد-انتفاضة-الخبز-في-المحافظات-وتكلفتها-الاقتصادية-تغطية-خاصة- .
186 ‘Abdel Rahman Badr, “Tawabae‘ al-Tanazol ‘Aan Tiran Wa Sanafir” [The consequences of concedingTiran and Sanafir], al-Bedaya, April 10, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/04/10/110788; “al-Qadaa’ al-Idari Yahkom Be-Botlan Itefaq Tiran Wa Sanafir” [The administrative judiciary voids the Tiran and Sanafir Agreement], BBC June 21, 2016, http://www.bbc.com/arabic/middleeast/2016/06/160621_egypt_saudi_border_agreement_void; ‘Abdo Mahmud, “al-Idariya al-‘Olya Tu’ajel al-Ta‘an ‘Ala Hokm ‘Tiran Wa Sanafir’ Le-22 Octubar” [Supreme administrative court postpones the government’s appeal regarding the ‘Tiran and Sanafir’ ruling to October 22], Sada al-Balad, October 8, 2016, http://www.elbalad.news/2436261; Mohamed Basal, “Qadiyat ‘Tiran Wa Sanafir’ Tasl al-Mahkama al-Dosturiya” [The ‘Tiran and Sanafir’ case reaches the Constitutional Court], Shoruq, August 15, 2016, https://www.shorouknews.com/news/view.aspx?cdate=15082016&id=9328eff6-d323-42bd-909f-53837b8e15f6; Mohamed Yahaya, “Mahkamat al-Ommur al-Mosta‘jala: Tiran Wa Sanafir Sa‘udiya” [Court of expedited matters: Tiran and Sanafir are Saudi], Misr al-‘Arabiya, September 29, 2016, http://www.masralarabia.com/حوادث/1267701-محكمة-الأمور-المستعجلة-تيران-وصنافير-سعودية; Mohamed Hamama, “al-Ommur al-Mosta‘jala Taqdi Be-Waqf Hokm al-Qadaa’ al-Idari Be-Misriyyat Tiran Wa Sanafir” [Court of expedited matters rules to void the administrative court’s ruling regarding the Egyptianness of Tiran and Sanafir], Mada Misr, September 29, 2016, http://www.madamasr.com/ar/2016/09/29/news/u/قضت-محكمة-الأمور-المستعجلة،-اليوم-الخ/; “Ahmed Mussa: Motazaheru 25 Abril Khawana Wa Jawasis” [Ahmed Mousa: The demonstrators of April 25th are traitors and spies], al-Misriyyun, April 24, 2016, https://almesryoon.com/story/879350/أحمد-موسى-متظاهرو-25-إبريل-خونة-وجواسيس; Basel Basha, “Hezb al-Tajammoe‘: al-Da‘wun Le-Mozaharat 25 Abril Madfuw‘un Men Jehat Amriykiya Wa Gharbiya Le-Isqat Misr” [The Unionist Party: Promoters of April 25th demonstrations are pushed by American and Western actors to bring down Egypt], al-Bedaya, April 23, 2016, http://albedaiah.com/news/2016/04/23/111730; “Nas Hokm al-Idariya al-‘Olya Be-Misriyyat Tiran Wa Sanafir” [The verdict of the Supremen Administrative Court regarding the Egyptianness of Tiran and Sanafir], Misr al-‘Arabiya, January 16, 2017, http://www.masralarabia.com/حوادث/1346254-نص-حكم-الإدارية-العليا-بمصرية-تيران-وصنافير; Sa‘ad Hussein, “Masdar Qadaa’i: ‘al-Dosturiya’ Qad Taqdi Be-Ilghaa’ Hokm ‘al-Idariya’ Be-Shaa’n Tiran Wa Sanafir” [Judicial source: The Supreme Constitutional Court may cancel the ruling of the Supreme Administrative Court regarding Tiran and Sanafir], Aswat Misriya, January 16, 2017, http://www.aswatmasriya.com/news/details/72195.
